All-State Prospect I.D
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| Zach Boyle | IN | Hamilton Southeastern | 2018 | 3B | |
| Edward Bransfield | IN | Carroll | 2020 | 3B | |
| Alec Brunson | IN | Dekalb | 2018 | C | Purdue University Fort Wayne |
| Jack Dewolf | IN | Hamilton Southeastern | 2019 | C | |
| Evan Doan | IN | Frankton | 2018 | 2B | |
| Jack Eckstein | IN | Chatard | 2018 | C | |
| Hayden Ellinger | IN | Bishop Dwenger | 2020 | 3B | |
| Nicholas Elmendorf | IN | North Central | 2018 | RHP | Franklin College |
| Max Engelking | IN | Guerin Catholic | 2020 | LHP | Eastern Illinois |
| Drew Fosler | IN | Fishers | 2018 | RHP | |
| Gabe Gladish | IN | Barr-Reeve | 2019 | RHP | |
| Kade Gorman | IN | Noblesville | 2018 | RHP | Goshen College |
| Jarret Gray | IN | Huntington North | 2018 | OF | |
| Michael Knecht | IN | Seymour | 2018 | OF | Franklin College |
| Evan Knowlton | IN | New Prairie | 2018 | SS | |
| Alex Koontz | IN | Churubusco | 2019 | 3B | |
| Joseph Kovets | IN | East Noble | 2018 | 2B | |
| Greyson LaRocque | IN | Leo | 2020 | OF | |
| Peyton Monnell | IN | Carroll | 2019 | OF | |
| Maxwell Moser | IN | Jay County | 2018 | 3B | Huntington University (IN) |
| Harrison Pittsford | IN | Edgewood | 2020 | C | |
| Jack Ross | IN | Harrison | 2019 | RHP | Taylor University |
| Cam Saunders | IN | Crawfordsville | 2019 | RHP | Indiana Wesleyan University |
| Jake Shirk | IN | Carroll | 2020 | 3B | Wright State |
| Cory Taylor | IN | Shelbyville | 2020 | SS | Eastern Michigan |
| EJ White IV | IN | Brebeuf Jesuit | 2018 | 3B | DePauw University |
| Owen Wiles | IN | Knightstown | 2018 | C |