2019 Underclass Games (2022s-2023s)
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| Joseph Barlovic | NJ | Bergenfield | 2023 | 1B | |
| Jake Beaney | NJ | Belvidere | 2022 | C | Brandeis University |
| Ryan Beauregard | NJ | Scotch Plains Fanwood | 2022 | C | Mount Union College |
| Nick Bergamotto | NJ | Caldwell | 2022 | 2B | Siena |
| Joseph Bernardo | NJ | DePaul Catholic | 2023 | C | Rutgers State University-Newark |
| Brian Bienus | NJ | Mount Olive | 2022 | 3B | Ithaca College |
| Evan Brown | NJ | Cherokee | 2023 | SS | Navy |
| Jake Burt | NJ | Wall | 2022 | RHP | |
| Daniel Callaghan | NY | Warwick Valley HS | 2023 | OF | |
| Matt Chapman | NJ | Cranford | 2023 | RHP | Salve Regina University |
| Alex Ciccone | NJ | South Brunswick | 2022 | SS | Arcadia University |
| Braden Connors | NJ | Bergen Catholic | 2023 | C | Holy Cross |
| Matt Dahl | NJ | Delbarton | 2023 | OF | Haverford College |
| Owen Davenport | NJ | Highland Regional | 2022 | RHP | Chestnut Hill College |
| Holden deJong | NJ | St. Augustine Prep | 2022 | LHP | New Jersey Tech |
| Brian Duarte | NJ | Paramus Catholic | 2022 | SS | |
| Logan Eilbacher | NJ | Notre Dame | 2023 | C | Catholic University |
| Daviel Fernandez | NJ | Gloucester Catholic | 2024 | RHP | Barry University |
| Jack Frankovic | NJ | Christian Brothers | 2022 | SS | Lehigh |
| CJ Fredericks | NJ | Northern Burlington | 2022 | 1B | |
| Ty Fredo | NJ | James Caldwell | 2023 | SS | Mount St. Mary's |
| Joe Giori | NJ | Steinert | 2022 | C | |
| Joey Gmitter | NJ | Hamilton East-Steinert | 2022 | 3B | Mercer County CC |
| AJ Gracia | NJ | Ranney School | 2023 | OF | Duke |
| James Grizzetti | NJ | Seton Hall Prep | 2023 | C | Salve Regina University |
| AJ Guiliana | CA | Torrey Pines | 2023 | SS | San Francisco |
| Jacob Hogan | NJ | Wayne Hills | 2022 | SS | |
| Ian Kaiser | NJ | Montville | 2023 | LHP | Binghamton |
| Zachary Konstantinovsky | NJ | North Brunswick | 2023 | RHP | Rutgers |
| Alex Kranzler | NJ | Old Tappan | 2023 | RHP | Vanderbilt |
| David Laman | NJ | Bergenfield | 2022 | OF | |
| Matt Leahy | NJ | Gloucester Catholic | 2023 | SS | Rider |
| Malik Little Jr. | NJ | Bergenfield | 2022 | SS | Caldwell University |
| Niko Logothetis | NJ | Ramapo | 2022 | RHP | Stockton University |
| Andrew Lombardi | NJ | Middletown North | 2022 | C | Millersville University |
| Danny Mack | NJ | Ramsey | 2022 | OF | |
| Alex Marino | NJ | Notre Dame | 2022 | 1B | |
| Maximus Martin | NJ | Moorestown | 2022 | SS | Kansas State |
| Xavier Massey | NJ | Audubon | 2022 | OF | Rutgers |
| Zachary McBride | NJ | Delbarton | 2023 | C | Trinity College (CT) |
| Kyle Neri | NJ | St. Augustine Prep | 2022 | OF | Bryant |
| Dylan Palmer | NJ | Notre Dame | 2022 | 2B | Hofstra |
| Samuel Parker | GA | Kennesaw Mountain | 2023 | OF | Georgia State |
| Sebastian Pisacreta | NJ | TNXL Academy | 2023 | C | Pittsburgh |
| Gianni Rana | NJ | Leonia | 2022 | SS | Montclair State University |
| Anthony Roldan | NJ | Bergenfield | 2022 | OF | Dominican College (NY) |
| Charlie Saul | NJ | Pascack Valley | 2023 | OF | Bryant |
| Ian Scalabrini | NJ | Don Bosco Prep | 2022 | 1B | |
| Jason Schooley | NJ | Cherokee | 2023 | C | Rowan University |
| Walter Schwartz | NJ | St Joseph High School | 2022 | RHP | Trinity College (CT) |
| Tony Silva | NJ | Cranford | 2022 | 2B | Colby College |
| Ryan Spina | NJ | Holy Spirit | 2022 | 3B | |
| Zach Stichweh | NJ | Don Bosco Prep | 2022 | RHP | Maryland |
| Jackson Stoll | NJ | Middletown South | 2023 | C | |
| Charlie Taub | NJ | Edison | 2023 | C | Maine |
| Ryan Taylor | NJ | St. Augustine Prep | 2022 | SS | Pennsylvania |
| Connor Watson | NJ | Morristown | 2023 | OF | |
| Brett Wehringer | NJ | Ranney School | 2023 | SS | Georgetown |
| Ryan Weingartner | NJ | St. Augustine Prep | 2022 | SS | St. Joseph's University |
| Matty Wright | NJ | Somerville | 2022 | OF | Stony Brook |