2021 Garden State Underclass Games
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| Christian Aiello | NJ | West Milford | 2022 | LHP | Rider |
| Anthony Anzaldi | NJ | Montclair | 2023 | LHP | New Jersey Tech |
| Carson Applegate | NJ | The Hun | 2022 | SS | Kentucky |
| Matt Augustin | NJ | Bishop Eustace | 2023 | RHP | Virginia |
| Christian Azcona | NJ | St Joseph High School | 2023 | 3B | Eastern Kentucky |
| Charles Batista | NJ | The Hun | 2024 | RHP | Penn State |
| Ryan Beauregard | NJ | Scotch Plains Fanwood | 2022 | C | Mount Union College |
| Justin Belford | NJ | Elizabeth | 2023 | 1B | |
| Dom Bello | FL | Bishop Moore Catholic | 2023 | C | Anderson University (SC) |
| Nick Bergamotto | NJ | Caldwell | 2022 | 2B | Siena |
| Brian Bienus | NJ | Mount Olive | 2022 | 3B | Ithaca College |
| Luke Billings | NJ | Robbinsville | 2024 | RHP | Wake Forest |
| Nicholas Bisaccia | NJ | New Providence | 2022 | SS | Seton Hall |
| Connor Bonham | NJ | Cumberland Regional | 2023 | RHP | |
| Brendan Buecker | NJ | Notre Dame | 2023 | C | Monmouth |
| Cole Campbell | NJ | Mainland Regional | 2022 | C | New Jersey Tech |
| Jack Cannizzaro | NJ | Don Bosco Prep | 2022 | C | James Madison |
| Robbie Carvelli | NJ | St. Joseph of Metuchen | 2023 | OF | Lehigh |
| Gabe Caso | NJ | West Morris Central | 2022 | C | Northampton CC |
| Christian Charalambous | NJ | Bergen Catholic | 2023 | LHP | Presbyterian |
| Jake Cheeseman | NJ | The Kings Christian | 2022 | SS | |
| Jeremy Cheeseman | NJ | Cherokee | 2022 | 3B | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Michael Chiaravallo | NJ | The Hun | 2023 | OF | Bucknell |
| Frank Ciccone | NJ | Pope John XXIII | 2022 | RHP | St. Joseph's University |
| Joe Cilea | NJ | Colts Neck | 2022 | C | Sacred Heart |
| Connor Cilento | NJ | Point Pleasant Boro | 2023 | SS | |
| Daniel Ciprian | NJ | Linden | 2023 | SS | Brookdale CC |
| Jude Clough | NJ | DePaul Catholic | 2023 | C | George Washington |
| Trevor Cohen | NJ | Holy Spirit | 2022 | OF | Rutgers |
| Michael Colonnello | NJ | Sayreville | 2023 | OF | Kean University |
| Nicholas Coniglio | NJ | Ranney | 2023 | RHP | Northeastern |
| Christian Coppola | NJ | Cedar Creek | 2022 | RHP | Rutgers |
| Jason Cozzi | NJ | Bridgewater-Raritan | 2023 | LHP | Massachusetts-Amherst |
| Zach Crotchfelt | NJ | Jackson Memorial | 2022 | LHP | Auburn |
| Gavin Degnan | NJ | Donovan Catholic | 2023 | OF | Pennsylvania |
| Tyler Del Vecchio | NJ | St Joseph High School | 2023 | 1B | |
| Michael Doran | NJ | Allentown | 2022 | 3B | |
| Colin Downlen | NJ | Middletown North | 2022 | RHP | Seton Hall |
| Logan Duffy | NJ | Manchester Township | 2022 | OF | Old Dominion |
| Landon Edwards | NJ | Kingsway Regional | 2023 | LHP | Coastal Carolina |
| Logan Eilbacher | NJ | Notre Dame | 2023 | C | Catholic University |
| Ryan Facinelli | NJ | Hunterdon Central | 2022 | SS | Bucknell |
| Daviel Fernandez | NJ | Gloucester Catholic | 2024 | RHP | Barry University |
| Andrew Fischer | NJ | Wall | 2022 | 1B | Tennessee |
| Chase Fischer | NJ | Hunterdon Central | 2022 | 1B | Rider |
| Aidan Folsom | NJ | Toms River South | 2022 | RHP | The College of Saint Elizabeth |
| Justin Ford | NJ | Roxbury | 2023 | 3B | Seton Hall |
| Jace Gilligan | NJ | Passaic County Tech | 2023 | C | St. Peters |
| Jonny Gilligan | NJ | PCTI | 2023 | SS | St. Peters |
| Andrew Goldan | NJ | St. Joe's Metuchen | 2022 | RHP | Rutgers |
| John Goodes | NJ | Rumson Fair-Haven | 2023 | RHP | Rutgers |
| Trevor Hansen | NJ | Montgomery | 2022 | OF | Manhattan |
| Martin Howell | NJ | Watchung Hills | 2023 | C | Penn State |
| Kai Hutchins | NJ | Pemberton Township | 2023 | OF | Manhattan |
| Alex Jankowski | NJ | Marlboro | 2021 | SS | Radford |
| Ian Kaiser | NJ | Montville | 2023 | LHP | Binghamton |
| Jackson Kraemer | NJ | The Hun | 2022 | OF | Wake Forest |
| JT Kroner | NJ | Colonia | 2022 | LHP | Rutgers |
| Malik Little Jr. | NJ | Bergenfield | 2022 | SS | Caldwell University |
| Nicolas Lorenzo | NJ | Pingry | 2023 | 2B | Richmond |
| Chris Maldonado | NJ | Seton Hall Prep | 2022 | SS | Vanderbilt |
| Maximus Martin | NJ | Moorestown | 2022 | SS | Kansas State |
| Marco Maselli | NJ | Delbarton | 2023 | OF | |
| Marcello Mastroianni | NJ | Ranney | 2023 | LHP | Georgetown |
| Kyle McCoy | NJ | Hunterdon Central | 2022 | LHP | Maryland |
| Charlie Meglio | NJ | Jackson Memorial | 2023 | SS | Campbell |
| Jake Memoli | NJ | Watchung Hills Regional | 2022 | RHP | Fairfield |
| Lorenzo Meola | NJ | Watchung Hills | 2022 | SS | Stetson |
| Cohl Mercado | NJ | St. Joseph Hammonton | 2022 | OF | Boston College |
| Christopher Montone | NJ | Williamstown | 2022 | RHP | Rider |
| Nazier Mule | NJ | PCTI | 2022 | RHP | Miami |
| Jimmy Mulvaney | NJ | St Joseph High School | 2023 | RHP | Fairfield |
| Rj Mustaro | NJ | Gloucester Catholic | 2023 | OF | |
| Nico Ong | NJ | Bloomfield | 2022 | C | Maryland, Baltimore County |
| Christian Ovecka | NJ | Bishop Eustace | 2023 | OF | Fordham |
| Brandon Padre | NJ | Hunterdon Central | 2022 | C | Manhattan |
| Christian Pareja | NJ | Passaic County Tech | 2022 | RHP | Coppin State |
| Brett Patten | NJ | Manasquan | 2023 | OF | St. John's |
| Rodney Pena | NY | Citius Prep | 2024 | RHP | Pittsburgh |
| Christian Petino Jr | NJ | Hunterdon Central | 2022 | OF | Caldwell University |
| Clayton Poliey | NJ | Don Bosco Prep | 2022 | RHP | Rider |
| D'Angelo Ponce | NJ | Ferris | 2023 | OF | Wilmington University (DE) |
| Colin Reilly | NJ | Christian Brothers Academy | 2022 | RHP | Tulane |
| Jack Renaud | NJ | Ranney | 2023 | RHP | Queens University (NC) |
| Luke Roccesano | NJ | Christian Brothers Academy | 2023 | RHP | Maryland |
| Kyle Rogers | NJ | Clifton | 2023 | LHP | St. Thomas Aquinas College |
| Ben Romano | NJ | The Hun | 2022 | OF | Tulane |
| Andrew Rubayo | NJ | Peddie | 2022 | RHP | Quinnipiac |
| Devin Russell | NJ | Mountain Lakes | 2022 | C | Maryland |
| Carsten Sabathia | NJ | Bergen Catholic | 2022 | 1B | Georgia Tech |
| Jason Schooley | NJ | Cherokee | 2023 | C | Rowan University |
| Kevin Scully | NJ | Pascack Hills | 2022 | RHP | James Madison |
| Griffin Seibel | NJ | Glen Ridge | 2023 | RHP | Xavier |
| Joe Stanzione | NJ | Middletown South | 2022 | 1B | Gardner-Webb |
| Tyler Stone | NJ | Somerville | 2022 | OF | Kean University |
| Nick Struble | NJ | Hackettstown | 2022 | 1B | |
| Nick Sulpizio | NC | Pro5 Academy | 2023 | RHP | Old Dominion |
| Ryan Taylor | NJ | St. Augustine Prep | 2022 | SS | Pennsylvania |
| Nick Tomasetto | NJ | West Deptford | 2023 | SS | Rutgers |
| Connor Watson | NJ | Morristown | 2023 | OF | |
| Carson Wehner | NJ | The Hun | 2022 | SS | |
| Brett Wehringer | NJ | Ranney School | 2023 | SS | Georgetown |
| Ryan Weingartner | NJ | St. Augustine Prep | 2022 | SS | St. Joseph's University |
| Aaron Winzinger | NJ | Hightstown | 2022 | RHP | Rider |
| Drew Wyers | NJ | Northern Burlington | 2022 | SS | Stetson |