2023 Garden State Underclass Games
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| Henry Ayers | NJ | Seton Hall Prep | 2025 | C | Middlebury College |
| Charles Batista | NJ | The Hun | 2024 | RHP | Penn State |
| Nicky Becker | NJ | Don Bosco Prep | 2025 | SS | Virginia |
| Rhys Bowie | NJ | Dwight Englewood | 2024 | LHP | Wake Forest |
| Matthew Brunner | NJ | Red Bank Catholic | 2024 | OF | |
| Luca Bruno | NJ | Mainland Regional | 2025 | LHP | St. Peters |
| Sean Budis | NJ | Brearley | 2025 | LHP | Boston College |
| Migueldavid Cabral | NJ | Westwood Regional | 2024 | C | |
| Jean Calderon | NJ | Union City | 2024 | SS | Monroe JC |
| Lorenzo Camilleri | NJ | St. Peter's Prep | 2025 | 1B | New Jersey Tech |
| Jayden Capindica | NJ | Immaculata | 2025 | OF | Iona |
| Jared Carlucci | NJ | Columbia | 2024 | RHP | Rutgers |
| Yomar Carreras | NJ | North Brunswick | 2024 | SS | Rutgers |
| Eric Cha | NJ | rabun gap | 2024 | 1B | Northeastern |
| Brett Chiesa | NJ | Cherokee | 2025 | 3B | Rowan University |
| Mason Christopher | NJ | Middletown South | 2024 | LHP | Seton Hall |
| Curtis Chropuvka | NJ | Ranney | 2025 | OF | Lafayette |
| Cullen Condon | NJ | Manasquan | 2024 | SS | Wofford |
| Michael Contiliano | NJ | Hunterdon Central | 2024 | OF | Seton Hall |
| Ryan Costello | NJ | Ranney School | 2024 | 1B | Louisiana State |
| Anthony Costello Jr | NJ | Don Bosco Prep | 2025 | LHP | Charleston Southern |
| Carter Cumiskey | NJ | Spotswood | 2025 | 1B | Seton Hall |
| Gabe Cushner | NJ | Don Bosco Prep | 2024 | C | Babson College |
| Louis D'Alessio | NJ | Middletown South | 2024 | OF | Alabama-Birmingham |
| Max Dantoni | NJ | Red Bank Catholic | 2025 | SS | Lehigh |
| Connor Darling | NJ | Northern Highlands | 2024 | RHP | Pennsylvania |
| Frank Dasti | NJ | Jonathan Dayton | 2025 | 3B | St. Joseph's University |
| Howard Tate DeRias | NJ | Gloucester Catholic | 2024 | RHP | Miami |
| Tony DiChiara | NJ | Homeschool | 2024 | C | Monmouth |
| Luke Dickerson | NJ | Morris Knolls | 2024 | SS | Virginia |
| John DiGregorio | NJ | Gill St. Bernards | 2024 | C | Purdue |
| Aiden Dill | NJ | Delbarton | 2024 | LHP | Seton Hall |
| John Donahue | NJ | Montgomery | 2025 | RHP | Seton Hall |
| Roger Dreher | NJ | Manahawkin | 2024 | RHP | USC Upstate |
| Sergio Droz | NJ | Millville | 2024 | SS | Maryland, Baltimore County |
| Christian Elliot | NJ | Mainland | 2024 | OF | |
| Ayden Ellis | NJ | High Point | 2025 | C | Rutgers |
| Joey Erace | NJ | St. Augustine Prep | 2025 | SS | Rutgers |
| Brandon Falco | NJ | Matawan Regional | 2024 | RHP | New Jersey Tech |
| John Carlos Franconere | NJ | Pope John XXIII | 2024 | LHP | Quinnipiac |
| Zach Fronio | NJ | North Hunterdon | 2025 | LHP | Boston College |
| Brett Gable | NJ | Cherokee | 2025 | LHP | Harvard |
| Everett Garber | NJ | Dwight-Englewood | 2024 | RHP | Bucknell |
| Ryder Garino | NJ | Cherry Hill West | 2024 | RHP | South Carolina |
| Jake Griess | NJ | Haddon Heights | 2024 | SS | Wagner |
| Sean Griggs | NJ | Red Bank Catholic | 2024 | 3B | Alabama |
| Dawson Guerard | NJ | Roxbury | 2025 | RHP | Stevens Institute of Technology |
| Luke Guire | NJ | Bordentown | 2025 | SS | Delaware |
| Joseph Haines | NJ | St. Peter's Prep | 2024 | C | Catholic University |
| James Hare | NJ | Ranney | 2025 | RHP | La Salle |
| Jack Harley | NJ | Delbarton | 2024 | 3B | Virginia Tech |
| Marcelo Harsch | NJ | Seton Hall Prep | 2025 | RHP | Wake Forest |
| Jordan Henriquez | NJ | Cherokee | 2024 | C | Harford CC |
| Ryan Holman | NJ | Delbarton | 2025 | RHP | Lehigh |
| Jake Howlett | NJ | Wall | 2024 | C | Monmouth |
| Grant Hunter | NJ | Lenape | 2024 | OF | Virginia Tech |
| Trent Jenks | NJ | Chatham | 2024 | OF | Hofstra |
| Bryson Kirby | NJ | Point Pleasant Boro | 2024 | RHP | Monmouth |
| William Kirk | NJ | Ramsey | 2024 | LHP | Virginia |
| James Kleiven | NJ | Randolph | 2024 | RHP | Miami |
| Matthew Kosuda | NJ | Governor Livingston | 2024 | 3B | William & Mary |
| Chase Kroberger | NJ | Moorestown | 2025 | OF | Alabama |
| Jayson Labrador | NJ | Immaculata | 2025 | SS | Babson College |
| Ryan Leach | NJ | Woodbridge | 2025 | RHP | Post University |
| Declan Leary | NJ | Red Bank Catholic | 2024 | RHP | |
| Chris Levonas | NJ | Christian Brothers Academy | 2024 | RHP | Wake Forest |
| Jake Lodgek | NJ | Mainland | 2025 | RHP | Miami |
| Landon Mack | NJ | Bishop Eustace Prep | 2024 | RHP | Rutgers |
| William Mahala | NJ | Seton Hall Prep | 2025 | OF | Virginia |
| Tommy Manzo | NJ | St Joseph's Montvale | 2024 | SS | Seton Hall |
| Jake Marciano | NJ | Donovan Catholic | 2024 | LHP | Virginia Tech |
| Andrew Marquis | NJ | Middletown South | 2024 | C | |
| Zach Maxwell | NJ | Delsea | 2024 | OF | |
| Dennis McCaffrey | NJ | Cranford | 2024 | OF | Tampa |
| Michael McGinley | NJ | Delsea Regional | 2024 | C | Rider |
| Jayden Mercado | NJ | Ferris | 2025 | OF | |
| Luke Monico | NJ | Ramsey | 2024 | 3B | Marist |
| Kellen Moore | NJ | Lawrence | 2024 | RHP | Lafayette |
| Owen O'Toole | NJ | Rumson-Fair Haven | 2025 | RHP | |
| Andrew Parisi | NJ | Ranney | 2025 | C | Fairleigh Dickinson University-Madison |
| Bruce Parker | NJ | Haddonfield Memorial | 2024 | SS | Rutgers |
| Dylan Passo | NJ | Red Bank Catholic | 2025 | 1B | Notre Dame |
| Michael Pierson | NJ | Shawnee | 2024 | 3B | St. Joseph's University |
| John Podgorski | NJ | St. Augustine Prep | 2024 | RHP | Villanova |
| Ryan Prior | NJ | Red Bank Catholic | 2025 | RHP | Virginia |
| Colin Richter | NJ | Roxbury | 2024 | OF | James Madison |
| JR Rosado | NJ | Bridgewater-Raritan | 2025 | C | St. Joseph's University |
| Julius Rosado | NJ | South River | 2025 | 3B | Rutgers |
| Nick Rotundo | NJ | West Morris Central | 2025 | LHP | |
| Chris Sand | NJ | North Hunterdon | 2025 | RHP | Rutgers |
| Paul Santos | NJ | Marlboro | 2024 | OF | St. Peters |
| Danny Scullion | NJ | Shawnee | 2024 | C | Harford CC |
| Cody Sherrer | NJ | North Warren | 2024 | RHP | |
| Michael Simone | NJ | Morris Knolls | 2024 | 1B | Manhattan |
| Brayden Simpson | NJ | Timber Creek | 2025 | C | McDaniel College |
| Drew Slomkowski | NJ | Nutley | 2025 | RHP | Seton Hall |
| Nathan Sofield | NJ | Pinelands Regional | 2025 | C | Presbyterian |
| Benjamin St Pierre | NJ | Montclair | 2025 | OF | Misericordia University |
| George Starr | NJ | Delsea Regional | 2024 | RHP | Goldey-Beacom |
| Jack Sweeney | NJ | Allentown | 2024 | OF | Rutgers |
| Evan Taylor | NJ | Ocean City | 2025 | RHP | Alabama |
| Payne Teel | NJ | Ramapo | 2024 | C | Scranton |
| AJ Terry | NJ | Randolph | 2025 | SS | North Carolina |
| Colin Thompson | NJ | Ocean City | 2025 | OF | |
| Ethan Tolbert | NJ | Moorestown | 2025 | SS | James Madison |
| Max Treonze | NJ | Rutgers Prep | 2024 | RHP | Lehigh |
| Danny Tsimbinos | NJ | Christian Brothers Academy | 2025 | C | Catholic University |
| Maclain Tufts | NJ | Pope John XXII | 2024 | SS | Longwood |
| Reid Uccello | NJ | Shawnee | 2024 | SS | Lehigh |
| Tyler Wiltsey | NJ | Audubon | 2025 | OF | Rutgers |
| Sam Winsett | NJ | Eastern Regional | 2024 | SS | Coastal Carolina |
| Luke Wood | NJ | Pennsville | 2025 | LHP | McDaniel College |
| Jon Young Jr | NJ | Cherry Hill West | 2024 | SS | Alabama |
| Christian Zebrowski | NJ | Delbarton | 2024 | RHP | Middlebury College |