Preseason All-State
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| David Antone | NY | Utica Proctor | 2019 | 3B | Frederick CC |
| Justin Augustine | NY | Greece Arcadia | 2018 | C | |
| Benjamin Avila | NY | The Harvey | 2019 | C | Grambling State |
| Cade Bacon | NY | CBA-Syracuse | 2020 | 3B | |
| Drew Bailey | NY | Mcquaid Jesuit | 2019 | OF | Mercyhurst University |
| Alex Bardo | NY | Corning Painted Post | 2018 | RHP | SUNY-Cortland |
| Samuel Barley | NY | Ithaca | 2018 | OF | |
| Liam Barry | NY | West Genesee | 2018 | RHP | |
| Benjamin Beratta | NY | Marcellus | 2018 | RHP | |
| Philip Bernstein | NY | Berkeley Carroll | 2018 | OF | |
| Joe Biancone | NY | John Jay - Cross River | 2019 | SS | George Washington |
| Chris Bonacci | NY | West Genesee | 2020 | OF | SUNY-Cortland |
| Evan Bowers | NY | SUNY Adirondack | 2018 | OF | SUNY-Adirondack CC |
| Drew Bristow | NY | Cicero-North Syracuse | 2019 | OF | UNC Asheville |
| Nick Brown | NY | Liverpool | 2018 | OF | |
| Trey Brown | NY | Aquinas Institute | 2018 | 2B | Monroe Community College |
| Tony Burlingame | NY | Horseheads | 2018 | OF | Fredonia State University |
| Vincent Caiati | NY | Afton | 2018 | C | Lackawanna JC |
| Noah Campanelli | NY | Mcquaid Jesuit | 2019 | SS | St. John Fisher College |
| Andrew Carroll | PA | Honesdale | 2019 | RHP | Lackawanna JC |
| Nicholas Castellana | NY | Lancaster | 2020 | C | Niagara |
| Adam Chase | NY | Webster Schroeder | 2018 | 1B | |
| Nick Chemotti | NY | West Genesee | 2020 | SS | SUNY-Cortland |
| Andrew Circelli | NY | New Hartford | 2018 | 3B | |
| Lewis Clarke | NY | Saratoga Springs | 2018 | OF | Manhattan |
| Ben Coates | NY | Westhill | 2019 | LHP | Canisius |
| Evan Crook | NY | Liverpool | 2019 | RHP | |
| Mike Deckert | NY | Midlakes | 2018 | RHP | |
| Michael DeStefano | NY | Liverpool | 2019 | SS | Canisius |
| Cade Dick | NY | St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute | 2020 | 2B | |
| Dominick DiRado | NY | Vestal | 2018 | LHP | Binghamton |
| Ethan Duda | NY | Albany Academy | 2019 | OF | Herkimer County CC |
| William Duncanson | NY | Fayetteville-Manlius | 2020 | C | |
| Erik Dusseldorp | NY | Roscoe | 2018 | LHP | SUNY-Oswego |
| Danny Elvers | NY | Lackawanna | 2018 | SS | |
| Andrew Fairbrother | NY | Williamsville North | 2019 | 3B | Niagara County CC |
| Connor Fenlong | NY | Gouverneur | 2018 | RHP | Wabash Valley JC |
| Nic Ferreira | NY | N/A | 2018 | ||
| Connor Fitzsimmons | NY | Pittsford Sutherland | 2019 | C | |
| Dante Furco | NY | Westhill | 2018 | OF | |
| Jack Gordon | NY | West Genesee | 2019 | RHP | Wilkes University |
| Caine Gregoire | NY | St. Francis | 2019 | C | Gannon University |
| TJ Gregory | NY | Chester Academy | 2018 | SS | St. Thomas Aquinas College |
| Jimmy Griffin | NY | East Syracuse-Minoa | 2018 | SS | |
| Tyler Griggs | NY | Mcquaid Jesuit | 2019 | 3B | Connecticut |
| David Gross | NY | CBA-Syracuse | 2018 | RHP | |
| Nathan Hampson | NY | Victor | 2018 | LHP | Monroe Community College |
| Caden Hann | NY | Webster Thomas | 2019 | RHP | |
| Luke Harder | NY | Liverpool | 2019 | OF | Suffolk University |
| Sam Heslin | NY | Horseheads | 2019 | C | |
| Nolan Hicks | NC | Combine Academy | 2021 | SS | Tampa |
| Ryan Hill | NY | Webster Thomas | 2018 | 2B | Monroe Community College |
| Jethro Hurt | NY | Norman Thomas | 2018 | C | Franklin Pierce |
| Nicholas Jaskolski | NY | Chaminade | 2018 | OF | Sacred Heart |
| Henry Juan | NY | Horseheads | 2020 | C | Williams College |
| Brandon Kelley | NY | Horseheads | 2018 | RHP | |
| Devin Kelly | NY | Midlakes | 2018 | OF | Finger Lakes CC |
| Alexander Kipp | NY | Vernon-Verona-Sherill | 2019 | 3B | Onondaga CC |
| Dean Langman | NY | New Hartford | 2018 | RHP | SUNY-Oneonta |
| Cole Laskowski | NY | St. Mary's | 2019 | 2B | Niagara County CC |
| Frank Levanti | NY | Baldwinsville | 2018 | 3B | SUNY-Oswego |
| Cory Listing | NY | LaSalle Institute | 2018 | OF | Bridgeport |
| Jared Lonergan | NY | Cicero-North Syracuse | 2018 | LHP | |
| Gabriel Lopez | NY | Monroe Woodbury | 2018 | RHP | Post University |
| Jake Manderson | NY | Ballston Spa | 2019 | C | George Mason |
| Jadon Masucci | NY | Webster Thomas | 2019 | RHP | |
| Bradley May | NY | West Genesee | 2019 | C | |
| Patrick May | NY | Charles W Baker/Baldwinsville | 2020 | SS | |
| Robby Merkov | NY | Webster Schroeder | 2019 | OF | |
| Jack Migliore | NY | Hamburg | 2019 | OF | Canisius |
| Joshua Miles | NY | Olean | 2018 | RHP | St. John Fisher College |
| Mathew Miller | NY | Benjamin Cardozo | 2018 | RHP | LIU Post |
| Gerard Mouton | NY | Liverpool | 2018 | 2B | Clarkson University |
| Justin Mytych | NY | Penfield | 2019 | RHP | |
| Sean O'Connor | NY | Fayetteville-Manlius | 2019 | 3B | Le Moyne College |
| Daniel Owen | NY | New Hartford | 2018 | RHP | College of Saint Rose |
| Owen Parliament | NY | LaFargeville | 2020 | RHP | Wofford |
| Thomas Peltier | NY | Niagara-Wheatfield | 2019 | LHP | Canisius |
| Cole Penders | NY | Brockport | 2018 | 2B | Brockport State |
| Andrew Perry | NY | Shenendehowa | 2018 | 3B | SUNY-Cortland |
| Justin Persse | NY | Cicero-North Syracuse | 2020 | LHP | |
| Tate Pierson | NY | Pittsford-Sutherland | 2020 | OF | |
| Trey Princiotto | NY | Horseheads | 2019 | SS | Herkimer County CC |
| Daniel Purcell | NY | West Genesee | 2018 | C | |
| Nathan Ray | NY | Baldwinsville | 2023 | C | Ithaca College |
| Seth Reisman | NY | Fayetteville-Manlius | 2019 | C | |
| Raymond Richards | NY | Spencerport | 2018 | RHP | |
| Jake Ring | NY | Pittsford-Mendon | 2018 | OF | |
| James Roeschlaub | NY | Auburn | 2018 | LHP | Cayuga Community College |
| Tyler Rosati | NY | Frankfort Schuyler | 2020 | 2B | |
| Steven Rossi | NY | Corning | 2018 | RHP | Suffolk University |
| Tommy Ryan | NY | Victor | 2018 | C | |
| Ethan Sarmiento | NY | The Harvey | 2019 | 3B | Massachusetts-Lowell |
| Jason Savacool | NY | Baldwinsville | 2020 | RHP | Maryland |
| Cregg Scherrer | NY | Skaneateles | 2019 | LHP | Albany |
| Tommy Scherrer | NY | Skaneateles | 2018 | RHP | Union College (NY) |
| Tim Schinto | NY | Cicero North Syracuse | 2018 | OF | SUNY-Oswego |
| James Sciortino | NY | Greece Athena | 2018 | SS | |
| Ryan Seburn | NY | East Syracuse-Minoa | 2018 | RHP | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Patrick Sherron | NY | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | RHP | Monroe Community College |
| Michael Siano | NY | Queensbury | 2018 | 1B | Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Benjamin Smart | NY | Home Schooled | 2019 | RHP | Cayuga Community College |
| Luke Smith | NY | Jamesville-Dewitt | 2018 | OF | Haverford College |
| Peter Smith | NY | Webster Schroeder | 2019 | RHP | |
| Tyler Smith | NY | Stony Brook | 2021 | C | St. Peters |
| Tyler Smith | NY | Fairport | 2018 | 2B | |
| Raymond Specht | NY | Rush-Henrietta | 2018 | SS | Niagara County CC |
| Dylan Steinman | NY | West Genesee | 2018 | RHP | Brockport State |
| Kobe Stenson | NY | Liverpool | 2020 | SS | Siena |
| David Stirpe | NY | Hilton | 2018 | SS | Messiah College |
| Ryan Syrko | NY | Liverpool | 2018 | 2B | |
| Christian Szablewski | NY | St. Marys | 2018 | OF | St. Bonaventure |
| Matthew Tarby | NY | Bishop Grimes | 2020 | RHP | Le Moyne College |
| Daniel Tirabassi | NY | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | 3B | Rochester |
| Kyle Vachon | NY | Glens Falls | 2019 | C | |
| Josh Van Bramer | NY | Fairport | 2019 | 1B | Alfred State College |
| Blake VanDreason | NY | Vernon-Verona-Sherrill | 2019 | 3B | SUNY-Oswego |
| Alexander Vogt | NY | Webster Schroeder | 2019 | OF | |
| Nicholas Vogt | NY | Webster Schroeder | 2019 | 1B | |
| Noah Walker | NY | Corning-Painted Post | 2019 | 2B | |
| Kyle Wallman | NY | Pittsford-Mendon | 2018 | C | |
| Frank Wayman III | NY | Horseheads | 2018 | 1B | Herkimer County CC |
| Gunar Weppner | NY | Williamsville East | 2019 | RHP | |
| Jacob Wheeler | NY | Liverpool | 2019 | OF | |
| Mason White | NY | Cicero North Syracuse | 2018 | RHP | |
| Colin Williams | NY | East Syracuse-Minoa | 2019 | C | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Nicholas Winslow | NY | Saratoga Central Catholic | 2020 | C | Herkimer County CC |
| Adam Wojciechowski | NY | West Seneca East | 2019 | C | Finger Lakes CC |
| Brett Young | NY | Albany Academy | 2018 | 3B | Virginia Commonwealth |
| EJ Zawadzki | NY | Westhill | 2018 | OF | |
| Philip Zollo | NY | Westhill | 2019 | SS | Le Moyne College |
| Cameron Zurat | NY | Williamsville North | 2019 | 1B |