Preseason All-State - Downstate
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| Darian Almonte | NY | Tappan Zee | 2019 | 2B | Rockland CC |
| Christopher Antonelli | NY | Archbishop Stepinac | 2020 | RHP | Felician College |
| Andres Auffant | NY | Center Moriches | 2019 | RHP | Franklin Pierce |
| Joseph Balducci | NJ | Don Bosco Prep | 2019 | LHP | |
| Thomas Barbera | NY | Fox Lane | 2021 | RHP | |
| Andrew Bonilla | NY | Valley Central | 2021 | 2B | SUNY-Oneonta |
| Connor Burton | NY | Pleasantville | 2019 | RHP | |
| Noah Cabassa | NY | North Rockland | 2019 | C | Lock Haven University |
| Justin Cabrera | NY | Cardinal Hayes | 2020 | 1B | Ulster County CC |
| Jason Castillo | NY | Salesian | 2020 | OF | St. Thomas Aquinas College |
| Stefano Cilluffo | NY | East Rockaway | 2019 | SS | |
| Anthony Cipri | NY | Archbishop Molloy | 2019 | 2B | Adelphi University |
| Joe Coopersmith | NY | Clarkstown North | 2019 | C | |
| Ruben Correa III | NY | Mount St. Michael Academy | 2020 | SS | Concordia College (NY) |
| Aidan Curry | NY | Fordham Prep | 2020 | RHP | Bucknell |
| Nick Cutaia | NY | Fox Lane | 2021 | 1B | Ithaca College |
| Ryan De La Rosa | NY | Christ the King | 2019 | RHP | Concordia College (NY) |
| Arvin Dela Cruz | NY | St. Raymond's | 2019 | 2B | |
| Jonathan Delgadillo | NY | Mount St. Michael Academy | 2018 | C | |
| Elijah Diaz | NY | All Hallows | 2019 | OF | Cornell |
| Ethan Diaz | NY | All Hallows | 2021 | OF | Wesleyan University |
| Evan Diaz | NY | All Hallows | 2021 | 3B | Wesleyan University |
| Tyler Edelman | NY | Suffern | 2019 | 2B | Ithaca College |
| EJ Exposito | NY | St. John the Baptist | 2019 | SS | New York Tech |
| Nicholas Fanelli | NY | New Paltz | 2020 | RHP | |
| Daniel Fichtl | NY | Bronx HS of Science | 2019 | 2B | |
| Thomas Fitzgerald | NY | Albertus Magnus | 2019 | RHP | |
| Sean Foody | NY | Tappan Zee | 2020 | RHP | Franklin Pierce |
| Aidan Gallagher | NY | Nanuet | 2019 | SS | Rockland CC |
| Joshua Gillison | NY | Hendrick Hudson | 2021 | OF | |
| Michael Hangan | NY | Iona Prep | 2019 | C | Rockland CC |
| Luke Harder | NY | Liverpool | 2019 | OF | Suffolk University |
| Carlos Herasme Jr. | NY | All Hallows | 2019 | 2B | Dominican College (NY) |
| Zachary Horowitz | NY | Oceanside | 2021 | C | SUNY-Old Westbury |
| Tommy Iazzetta | NY | Westlake | 2019 | OF | Roanoke College |
| Sam Keller | NY | School of the Future | 2019 | RHP | |
| Mason Ladlee | NY | Monroe Woodbury | 2019 | LHP | |
| Jack Laughlin | NY | Walter Panas | 2021 | RHP | SUNY - Cobleskill |
| Declan Lavelle | NY | Rye | 2020 | RHP | Fordham |
| Ulysses Luciano | NY | Riverdale Kingsbridge Academy | 2019 | C | Saint Michael's College |
| Max Luke | GA | North Gwinnett | 2020 | 1B | Georgia Highlands JC |
| Ryan Markowitz | NY | St. Peters | 2019 | OF | Neumann College |
| Christopher Marshiano | NY | Herricks | 2019 | RHP | |
| Matt Nichols | NY | Byram Hills | 2021 | OF | Gettysburg College |
| Gavin Noriega | NY | Salesian | 2020 | 1B | Marist |
| Ryan O'Connell | ME | Bridgton Academy | 2019 | OF | Nichols College |
| Luke Padian | NY | Fordham Prep | 2020 | 1B | Amherst College |
| Thomas Parisi | NY | Somers | 2020 | OF | Union College (NY) |
| Aaron Perez | NY | All Hallows | 2019 | SS | Maryland |
| Justin Perrotta | NY | Fordham Prep | 2019 | SS | Tufts University |
| Christopher Polgano | NY | St. Raymonds | 2019 | 3B | Felician College |
| Connor Popp | NY | Rye | 2020 | 3B | |
| Joseph Richter | NY | North Rockland | 2019 | RHP | |
| Eli Rosenshine | NY | Stepinac | 2020 | SS | |
| Alex Santos | NY | Mount St. Michael Academy | 2020 | RHP | Maryland |
| Giovanni Sarchese | NY | Archbishop Molloy | 2020 | 3B | |
| Jason Sebastiano | NY | St. Edmund Preparatory | 2020 | 3B | SUNY-Purchase |
| Gregory Shaw III | NY | Cornwall | 2022 | 3B | Manhattan |
| Luke Shliger | NY | Trinity Pawling | 2020 | C | Maryland |
| Jonathan Sica | NY | Yorktown | 2021 | 3B | |
| Justin Sierra | NY | Monsignor Scanlan | 2019 | OF | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Marcus Smith | SC | P27 Academy | 2022 | SS | McLennan CC |
| Tyler Smith | NY | Stony Brook | 2021 | C | St. Peters |
| Jason Sosa | NY | Yonkers | 2019 | 1B | |
| Marc Stockhausen | NY | St. Raymonds | 2019 | 3B | Rockland CC |
| Alex Ungar | NY | Connetquot | 2020 | 3B | Albany |
| Diego Urreta | NY | The Harvey School | 2021 | SS | Monroe College |
| Joshua Vega | NY | Christ the King | 2019 | RHP | |
| Nickolas Venuti | NY | Stepinac | 2019 | OF | College of Mount St. Vincent |
| Austin Wainer | GA | Johns Creek | 2020 | RHP | Bryant |
| Eric Yost | NY | Fordham Prep | 2020 | RHP | Northeastern |