New York Open ID (Registration Closed)
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| Justus Acosta | NY | Holy Cross | 2017 | OF | |
| Dylan Ahmad | NY | Florida homeschool | 2020 | 3B | |
| Peyton Baker | PA | Delaware Valley | 2017 | RHP | |
| Joseph Benish | NY | Union Endicott | 2017 | RHP | |
| Trevor Bertsch | PA | Delaware Valley | 2016 | 2B | Lebanon Valley College |
| Thomas Beyer | NY | Owego Free Academy | 2018 | OF | |
| DeAndre Bowens | NY | Monticello | 2018 | C | Hudson Valley CC |
| Nicholas Boyle | NY | Chenango Forks | 2018 | OF | Keuka College |
| Angelo Brucculeri | NY | Syosset | 2017 | OF | |
| Joseph Caba | NY | Grand Street Campus | 2017 | OF | Connors State JC |
| John Cady | NY | Shenendehowa | 2017 | LHP | Albany |
| Andrew Carroll | PA | Honesdale | 2019 | RHP | Lackawanna JC |
| Brandon Chavarria | NY | Roy C. Ketcham | 2017 | OF | |
| Jordan Congdon | NY | Maine Endwell | 2017 | RHP | |
| Daniel Cordero | NY | Benjamin Cardozo | 2018 | 3B | |
| Thomas Decker | NY | Tri-Valley | 2016 | 3B | Prince George's CC |
| Erik Dusseldorp | NY | Roscoe | 2018 | LHP | SUNY-Oswego |
| Milton Edmonds | NY | Greenville | 2018 | 2B | Endicott College |
| EJ Exposito | NY | St. John the Baptist | 2019 | SS | New York Tech |
| Frank Giambra | NY | Archbishop Molloy | 2017 | OF | |
| Austin Gilpin | PA | Wallenpaupack | 2017 | 3B | Lock Haven University |
| Ryan Hill | NY | Webster Thomas | 2018 | 2B | Monroe Community College |
| Andrew Huffman | NY | Rondout Valley | 2017 | RHP | Brockport State |
| Jethro Hurt | NY | Norman Thomas | 2018 | C | Franklin Pierce |
| Drew Jemison | NY | Monroe-Woodbury | 2018 | 3B | |
| Noah John | NY | Albany | 2017 | SS | |
| David Kale | NY | Lakeland | 2017 | OF | |
| Tyler Kirsten | PA | Wallenpaupack | 2018 | SS | Scranton |
| Ryan Lanaro | NY | Mohonasen | 2017 | SS | Albany |
| Jack Leahey | NY | Warwick | 2018 | RHP | Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Jeremy Lieberman | NY | Liberty | 2018 | C | |
| Cory Listing | NY | LaSalle Institute | 2018 | OF | Bridgeport |
| Irving Lora | NY | Manhattan Center | 2016 | LHP | Bronx CC |
| Kevin McCarthy | NY | Monticello | 2017 | 1B | |
| Jacob Miller | NY | Valley Central | 2017 | C | |
| Isaiah Mirabal | NY | Benjamin Cardozo | 2017 | C | Connors State JC |
| Christopher Moreno | NY | Benjamin Cardozo | 2018 | OF | |
| Austin Mosher | NY | Valley Central | 2018 | RHP | |
| Brandon Murray | NY | John S. Burke Catholic | 2017 | 1B | |
| Nick Myers | NY | Broadalbin-Perth | 2018 | SS | |
| Ryan O'Connell | ME | Bridgton Academy | 2019 | OF | Nichols College |
| Skyler Ohrvall | NY | John Jay-East Fishkill | 2017 | OF | |
| Justin Orlando | NY | Burnt Hills-Ballston Lake | 2017 | SS | |
| Justin Pacheco | CT | Loomis Chaffee | 2018 | RHP | Marist |
| Joe Palko | NY | Shenendehowa | 2017 | OF | |
| Mike Pascoe | NY | Arlington | 2016 | RHP | San Jacinto JC |
| Zachary Pruden | NY | Seton Catholic | 2018 | SS | |
| Steven Rizzo | NY | St. Anthonys | 2019 | OF | Franklin & Marshall College |
| Jesse Romao | NY | Saunders Trade & Technical | 2018 | 3B | Dutchess CC |
| Santino Rosso | NY | Victor | 2019 | SS | Hofstra |
| Anthony Russo | NY | Arlington | 2018 | RHP | |
| Brandon Smith | NY | Mohonasen | 2017 | C | |
| Dylan Smith | NY | Livingston Manor | 2017 | LHP | Sullivan County CC |
| Michael Spulnick | NY | Shenendehowa | 2017 | 2B | |
| Justin Stasiak | PA | Pleasant Valley | 2018 | OF | |
| William Van Beusekom | NY | Christian Brothers Academy (Albany) | 2016 | RHP | Marist |
| Mason Vaughan | NY | Seton Catholic Central | 2018 | 1B | Manhattan |
| Hamley Volquez | NY | Manhattan Center | 2016 | SS | City College of New York |