Preseason All-State
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| Kyle Bailey | NY | Saratoga Central Catholic School | 2016 | LHP | |
| Peter Battaglia III | NY | Williamsville North | 2016 | 1B | Niagara |
| DJ Berry | NY | Brighton | 2017 | OF | Southern |
| Garrett Boldt | NY | Olean | 2017 | OF | Niagara County CC |
| Trevor Bradshaw | NY | Oswego | 2016 | SS | |
| Alex Canty | NY | Batavia | 2016 | SS | |
| Matt Carroll | NY | Aquinas Institute of Rochester | 2016 | C | Niagara |
| Leugim Castillo | NY | Lancaster | 2017 | OF | Oklahoma |
| Stephen Centorani | NY | Windsor | 2016 | RHP | East Stroudsburg University |
| Matthew Cerrillo | NY | Saint Francis High School | 2016 | C | |
| Irvin E Cespedes | NY | Lajara Baseball Academic - DR | 2016 | SS | Bryan College |
| Benjamin Closson | NY | Lancaster Central | 2016 | C | |
| Joey Coene | NY | Webster Thomas | 2016 | 2B | |
| Wyatt Conklin | NY | Bloomfield | 2016 | LHP | Keuka College |
| Tanner Cooper | NY | Canandaigua Academy | 2017 | RHP | Penn State |
| Griff DeMayo | NY | Hamburg | 2016 | 3B | Hilbert College |
| Haydn Demers-St.Hilaire | NY | St. Lawrence HS | 2016 | LHP | Utica University |
| Michael Diehr | NY | Elmira | 2016 | RHP | |
| Zach Durfee | NY | Ballston Spa | 2016 | OF | Siena |
| Benjamin Ellsworth | NY | Ballston Spa High School | 2016 | 1B | |
| Ryan Enos | NY | Oriskany | 2017 | SS | SUNY-Oswego |
| Antonio Fisher | NY | Hudson | 2017 | C | Keuka College |
| Kurt Forsell | NY | Shenendehowa | 2017 | OF | St. John Fisher College |
| William Frank | NY | St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute | 2016 | RHP | Canisius |
| Nate Grimm | NY | Webster Thomas | 2016 | C | |
| Robert Gruber | NY | Frontier | 2017 | LHP | Niagara County CC |
| James Hartunian | NY | Bethlehem High School | 2016 | SS | |
| Troy Hattala | NY | Orchard Park | 2017 | C | |
| Parker Hendershot | NY | Tioga Central | 2017 | 3B | Penn State |
| Danny Hobbs | NY | Saratoga Springs | 2016 | RHP | Siena |
| Kenneth Howe | NY | Mount Morris Central | 2016 | RHP | Keuka College |
| Dylan Jones | NY | Averill Park | 2016 | RHP | Brockport State |
| Cody Kaestle | NY | Baldwinsville | 2016 | RHP | Herkimer County CC |
| Bret Kelly | NY | Tonawanda High School | 2016 | OF | |
| Zack Kesterson | NY | New Hartford | 2015 | SS | Duke |
| Dylan Klock | NY | St. Johnsville | 2016 | SS | St. Thomas Aquinas College |
| Rocco Leone | NY | Liverpool | 2016 | 2B | SUNY-Oswego |
| Ryan Marketell | NY | Webster Thomas | 2016 | RHP | Monroe Community College |
| Brett Migliore | NY | Wellsville | 2016 | SS | Canisius |
| Matthew Miller | NY | Bethlehem Central High School | 2016 | C | |
| Maddux Minton | NY | Livonia | 2016 | RHP | |
| Russell Mistretta | NY | Canisius High School | 2016 | OF | Mercyhurst University |
| Benjamin Monti | NY | Lancaster | 2016 | C | Mercyhurst University |
| Allen Murphy | NY | Bolivar-Richburg Central | 2016 | SS | |
| Wyatt Myers | NY | Chittenango | 2016 | SS | Buffalo |
| Scott Neu | NY | Churchville-Chili | 2016 | RHP | Keuka College |
| Jeffrey Palczewski | NY | Orchard Park | 2016 | 3B | Buffalo |
| Davis Payne | NY | Christian Brothers Academy | 2017 | 1B | Richmond |
| Frankie Pizzo | NY | Shenendehowa | 2016 | 3B | College of Saint Rose |
| Evan Plante | NY | Christian Brothers Academy | 2015 | LHP | Potomac State JC of West Virginia |
| Kobie Punchard | NY | Thomas A Edison | 2016 | RHP | |
| Mitchell Rosati | NY | Canisius | 2017 | OF | |
| Steven Rossi | NY | Corning | 2018 | RHP | Suffolk University |
| Sean Sheets | NY | Red Jacket Central | 2016 | 2B | |
| Jacob Sisto | NY | Liverpool | 2017 | C | SUNY-Cortland |
| Jake Smith | NY | Bethlehem Central High School | 2016 | OF | |
| Francisco Stec | NY | Schenectady | 2016 | OF | |
| Alec Teska | NY | Cato-Meridian | 2017 | RHP | St. John Fisher College |
| Zachary Turner | NY | Corning | 2017 | SS | |
| Jacob Victor | NY | St. Francis High School | 2016 | OF | Canisius |
| Dylan Vincent | NY | Olean | 2018 | OF | Canisius |
| Dillan Wilkinson | NY | Liverpool | 2016 | OF | |
| Jake Woodrich | NY | Orchard Park | 2016 | OF | Canisius |
| Dan Yankowski | NY | Ichabod Crane Central | 2016 | RHP | |
| Mike Zimmerman | NY | Canandaigua Academy | 2016 | RHP |