Rising Stars - Long Island
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| Caleb Aurelien | NY | St. Anthony's | 2023 | OF | Swarthmore College |
| Jordan Babbo | NY | Calhoun | 2023 | LHP | |
| Aidan Bardi | NY | Wantagh | 2024 | SS | Maine |
| Ryan Carroll | NY | Kellenberg | 2023 | RHP | |
| Christian Corey | NY | Locust Valley | 2023 | RHP | St. Peters |
| Maximo Del Pino | NY | Fordham Prep | 2023 | OF | Massachusetts Institute of Technology |
| Vincent Favata | NY | Syosset | 2024 | OF | Mount St. Mary's |
| Michael Feldman | NY | East Meadow | 2023 | 3B | |
| Daniel Kollmeier | NY | Holy Trinity | 2023 | 2B | Corning CC |
| Justin Kollmeier | NY | Holy Trinity | 2023 | LHP | Corning CC |
| Ryan Kurz | NY | St. Anthony's | 2023 | LHP | |
| JJ Palumbo | NY | WT Clarke | 2023 | C | SUNY-Purchase |
| Nicholas Pusinelli | NY | Saint Anthony's | 2023 | RHP | College of Staten Island |
| Christian Quintana-Quirindongo | NY | N/A | 2025 | OF | |
| Nico Quiroz | NY | Holy Trinity | 2023 | OF | Thomas Jefferson University |
| Joseph Santos | NY | Calhoun | 2024 | LHP | College of Mount St. Vincent |
| James Sill | NY | Division Avenue | 2023 | 1B | Hudson Valley CC |
| Thomas Skrobe | NY | Fordham Prep | 2023 | RHP | Holy Cross |
| Tyler Steinberg | NY | Syosset | 2023 | 2B | |
| BRANDON TAUBER | NY | East Meadow | 2023 | OF |