2023 OHSBCA Underclassmen Showcase
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| Caden Ammon | OH | Elder | 2024 | 3B | Findlay |
| Mason Ashby | OH | North Canton Hoover | 2024 | SS | |
| Bridger Bischof | OH | Kenston | 2024 | LHP | |
| Jaxon Brown | OH | Lexington | 2024 | C | Bowling Green State |
| Chase Chopin | OH | Jonathan Alder | 2024 | OF | Bowling Green State |
| Caden Coblentz | OH | Hiland | 2025 | RHP | Malone University |
| Caden Conn | OH | Wheelersburg | 2024 | LHP | Mount Vernon Nazarene University |
| Brayden Curlis | OH | Elder | 2024 | SS | Bowling Green State |
| Jeriah Davis | OH | Uniontown Lake | 2024 | OF | |
| William Donahoe | OH | Urbana | 2024 | SS | |
| Casey Doner | OH | Mason | 2024 | OF | |
| Connor Estep | OH | Wheelersburg | 2024 | SS | Mount Vernon Nazarene University |
| Hayden Frey | OH | Troy | 2025 | LHP | Toledo |
| Drew Hammond | OH | Northmor | 2024 | RHP | Findlay |
| Matty Helms | OH | Badin | 2024 | RHP | Northern Kentucky |
| Kaden Holman | OH | Upper Sandusky | 2024 | SS | Findlay |
| Grant Jolly | OH | Wapakoneta | 2025 | RHP | Marshall |
| LT Jordan | OH | Waverly Tigers | 2024 | SS | |
| Riley Kearns | OH | Vermilion | 2024 | RHP | Wittenberg University |
| Layne Keller | OH | Jackson | 2025 | C | Malone University |
| Gregory Kennedy | OH | Jonathan Alder | 2024 | RHP | Lake Erie College |
| Keegan Knupp | OH | Olentangy Orange | 2025 | 3B | Eastern Michigan |
| Joseph Lehner | OH | Stow | 2024 | SS | |
| Wyatt Lidke | OH | Olentangy Orange | 2025 | OF | |
| Tanyon McComb | OH | Indian Valley | 2024 | C | |
| Colin Milligan | OH | Rutherford B Hayes | 2024 | RHP | Eastern Michigan |
| Aaron Moss | OH | University School | 2025 | SS | Kenyon College |
| Landyn Patterson | OH | Unioto | 2024 | 3B | |
| Tannar Patterson | OH | Heath | 2025 | SS | Vincennes JC |
| KB Perkins | OH | Unioto | 2025 | LHP | Findlay |
| Braxton Prosser | OH | Galion | 2025 | C | Youngstown State |
| Tate Queen | OH | Lucasville Valley | 2025 | 3B | |
| Dylan Rieck | OH | Lakota East | 2024 | C | Earlham College |
| Garrett Roach | OH | Jonathan Alder | 2024 | 2B | Ohio Dominican University |
| Anthony Robinson | OH | Kings | 2024 | RHP | |
| Michael Romano | OH | Stow-Munroe Falls | 2024 | SS | |
| Brody Saunders | OH | St Clairsville | 2025 | RHP | Ashland University |
| Cody Shaw | OH | Defiance | 2025 | RHP | Findlay |
| Bryson Shumate | OH | Buckeye Valley | 2024 | RHP | Ohio Dominican University |
| Tucker Snyder | OH | Harrison Central | 2025 | OF | |
| Otto Solorzano | OH | Waynedale | 2024 | LHP | |
| Drew Stevens | OH | Mason | 2024 | 3B | Ashland University |
| Sebastian Stevens | OH | Ottawa Hills | 2024 | LHP | Findlay |
| Evan Tice | OH | East Liverpool | 2024 | C | Mercyhurst University |
| Jakob Tipton | OH | Portsmouth West | 2024 | C | |
| Jack Weldon | OH | Hudson | 2024 | RHP | |
| Grant Wheeler | OH | Minford | 2024 | SS | Mount Vernon Nazarene University |