2019 NYS Games
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| Bryan Aduddle | NY | Williamsville North | 2020 | RHP | Canisius |
| Dawson Aitken | NY | Guilderland | 2020 | RHP | Skidmore College |
| Jagger Alberici | NY | Liverpool | 2020 | SS | |
| Matthew Alexander | NY | Jamesville-Dewitt | 2021 | 2B | Bucknell |
| Kyle Allen | NY | Longwood | 2020 | 3B | New Haven |
| Kyle Andrews | NY | Croton Harmon | 2020 | 3B | |
| Paul Andrews | NY | Arlington | 2020 | OF | |
| Reynaldo Angeles | NY | Benjamin Cardozo | 2021 | SS | Sullivan County CC |
| Carlos Anziani | NY | P27 Academy | 2020 | RHP | Michigan |
| John Arnold | NY | Fayetteville-Manlius | 2020 | RHP | |
| Luke Arvantides | NY | Baldwinsville | 2021 | LHP | Niagara |
| Carson Ashby | NY | Jordan Elbridge | 2020 | 2B | |
| Harrison Ashley | CT | Brookfield | 2020 | RHP | |
| Chris AuClair | NY | Baldwinsville | 2021 | LHP | D'Youville College |
| Nicholas Badillo | FL | IMG Academy | 2022 | C | Winthrop |
| Anthony Barone | NY | Clarkstown South | 2020 | C | SUNY-Oswego |
| Brody Bartenstein | NY | Corning | 2021 | C | Washington & Jefferson College |
| Quin Barton | NY | Schoharie | 2022 | 2B | Keene State College |
| Angelo Bartziokas | NY | Minisink Valley | 2021 | RHP | Iona |
| Evan Bean | NY | Shenendehowa | 2020 | OF | |
| Jack Beauchamp | NY | Mcquaid Jesuit | 2021 | OF | |
| Julian Belardo | NY | Kellenberg | 2020 | SS | Penn State University-Harrisburg |
| David Belsito | NY | St. Francis | 2020 | C | Brockport State |
| Mike Benedetto | NY | Holland Patent | 2021 | 2B | Onondaga CC |
| David Bernard Jr | NY | Schenectady | 2022 | 1B | Herkimer County CC |
| Brandon Biggane | NY | Columbia | 2021 | C | Bates College |
| Ryan Birchard | NY | Auburn | 2021 | RHP | Niagara County CC |
| Owen Birkman | NY | Williamsville South | 2020 | C | Albany |
| Chris Bonacci | NY | West Genesee | 2020 | OF | SUNY-Cortland |
| Devin Boone | NY | Warwick | 2020 | SS | Marist |
| Joseph Bossinas | NY | Ossining | 2021 | 1B | Dean College |
| Liam Bowes | NY | Shoreham Wading River | 2022 | C | Fordham |
| Gavyn Boyle | SC | P27 Academy | 2022 | OF | Southern Indiana |
| Xander Burch | NY | Thomas A. Edison | 2021 | LHP | |
| Troy Butler | NY | Fort Plain | 2021 | RHP | Herkimer County CC |
| Justin Cabrera | NY | Cardinal Hayes | 2020 | 1B | Ulster County CC |
| Freddie Callo | NY | Marlboro | 2020 | LHP | Hudson Valley CC |
| Coltrane Calloway | NY | Bay Shore | 2021 | OF | Seton Hall |
| Nicolas Campagnuolo | NY | WT Clarke | 2020 | SS | New Haven |
| Devin Campbell | NY | Guilderland | 2020 | 2B | SUNY-Oswego |
| Tyler Campobasso | NY | Yorktown | 2020 | OF | |
| Matthew Canizares | NY | Monsignor McClancy | 2022 | OF | Houston |
| Miles Capobianco | NY | John Jay | 2021 | OF | Occidental College |
| Anthony Caputo | NY | Walter Panas | 2021 | OF | Concordia College (NY) |
| Robert Carbone | NY | Valhalla | 2020 | LHP | Salve Regina University |
| Cal Caruso | NY | Monroe Woodbury | 2020 | 3B | Lesley University |
| Jon Casieri | NY | Croton Harmon | 2020 | 2B | |
| Dominic Cassata | NY | St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute | 2020 | OF | |
| Carlos Castillo | NY | Grand St. Campus | 2020 | SS | Connors State JC |
| Evan Chaffee | NY | Hamburg | 2022 | LHP | Alabama |
| Aidan Chamberlin | NY | Corning- Painted Post | 2022 | RHP | Navy |
| Christopher Champlin | NY | South Kortright | 2020 | C | Post University |
| Erik Charnetski | NY | Elmira-Notre Dame | 2020 | OF | |
| Chance Checca | NY | Ballston Spa | 2021 | 3B | Herkimer County CC |
| Alex Chrisman | NY | Horseheads | 2022 | SS | Elmira College |
| Aidan Clatur | TN | Lipscomb Academy | 2021 | 2B | |
| Caden Clow | NY | Unatego | 2020 | OF | Herkimer County CC |
| Daniel Cohen | NY | South Glens Falls | 2022 | RHP | Yale |
| Stephen Collica | NY | Holy Trinity | 2020 | C | |
| Frankie Collora | NY | Ward Melville | 2020 | RHP | SUNY-Cortland |
| Jake Conklin | NY | Fairport | 2020 | RHP | Tyler JC |
| Jacob Contois | NY | Shaker | 2021 | OF | Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute |
| Tory Cooks | NY | Millennium | 2021 | OF | Earlham College |
| Kevin Correa | NY | Marlboro | 2020 | C | |
| Shane Corsi | NY | Seaford | 2020 | OF | |
| Vincent Corso | NY | Harrison | 2020 | RHP | Richmond |
| Chris Costaro | NY | Bellmore JFK | 2020 | 1B | Ithaca College |
| Carson Cotugno | NY | Amsterdam | 2021 | RHP | Wake Forest |
| Andrew Cubberly | NY | Arlington | 2020 | RHP | Quinnipiac |
| Ryan Culhane | NY | Clarence | 2020 | RHP | Brockport State |
| Christopher Cumbo | NY | W Tresper Clarke | 2020 | 2B | St. Thomas Aquinas College |
| Joseph Curreri | PA | Honesdale | 2023 | RHP | Hofstra |
| Aidan Curry | NY | Fordham Prep | 2020 | RHP | Bucknell |
| Tyler Curtis | NY | Greece Athena | 2020 | OF | |
| Nick Cutaia | NY | Fox Lane | 2021 | 1B | Ithaca College |
| Patrick Dalton | NY | Bethpage | 2021 | RHP | SUNY-Cortland |
| Cooper Danskin | NY | Lansingburgh | 2021 | C | |
| Jake Danyluk | NY | Newburgh Free Academy | 2020 | LHP | SUNY-Oswego |
| Mason Davis | NY | Clarence | 2020 | C | Brockport State |
| Kyle DeCresce | NY | Burnt Hills-Ballston Lake | 2022 | 3B | St. Thomas Aquinas College |
| Jackson Defayette | NY | Schalmont | 2020 | OF | Albany |
| Jeremy Delamota | MA | Berkshire | 2021 | OF | Monroe College |
| Jaden DeLawder | NY | FDR | 2021 | C | Binghamton |
| Nate Deluke | NY | Burnt Hills-Ballston Lake | 2021 | 1B | |
| Owen DeMember | NY | Elmira | 2020 | OF | Pittsburgh-Bradford |
| Evan Dempsey | PA | Abington Heights | 2020 | OF | SUNY-Oswego |
| Marc DeNunzio | NY | Westlake | 2021 | LHP | Lackawanna JC |
| Joe Dev | NY | HS | 2021 | 1B | |
| Ethan Diaz | NY | All Hallows | 2021 | OF | Wesleyan University |
| Evan Diaz | NY | All Hallows | 2021 | 3B | Wesleyan University |
| Yosmill Diaz | NY | Citius Prep | 2020 | C | Dyersburg State CC |
| Nick DiCarlo | NY | St Joseph's Collegiate Institute | 2021 | OF | Iona |
| Cade Dick | NY | St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute | 2020 | 2B | |
| Jake DiFede | NY | Lakeland | 2020 | OF | |
| Allan Dilone Rodriguez | NY | The Harvey | 2020 | OF | Wheaton College (MA) |
| Christian Dinallo | NY | John Jay - Cross River | 2020 | C | Ursinus College |
| Christian Diorio | NY | Marlboro | 2020 | OF | |
| Randy Dodig | NY | Saugerties | 2020 | SS | |
| Andrew Dongelewic | NY | Shaker | 2022 | RHP | Hudson Valley CC |
| Jared Drake | NY | Fairport | 2020 | RHP | DeSales University |
| Ethan Drinon | NY | Schoharie | 2021 | OF | Keystone College |
| Zakary Droukas | CT | Brookfield | 2021 | 2B | Massachusetts-Dartmouth |
| Sawyer Duarte | NY | Chaminade | 2020 | SS | Middlebury College |
| Jack Duffek | NY | Orchard Park | 2020 | 1B | |
| Connor Eisenmann | NY | Frontier Senior | 2020 | RHP | Albany |
| Zachary Eldred | NY | Columbia | 2020 | OF | |
| Scott Ennist Jr. | NY | FDR | 2022 | OF | Chestnut Hill College |
| Benjamin Eodice | NY | Niagara-Wheatfield | 2021 | RHP | Niagara County CC |
| Carmen Erno | NY | Columbia | 2020 | RHP | Russell Sage College |
| Robert Erno | NY | Columbia | 2021 | RHP | |
| Brendan Espinal | NY | Shenendehowa | 2020 | OF | SUNY-Adirondack CC |
| Sean Evangelista | NY | Citius Prep Academy | 2022 | OF | Felician College |
| Robert Evans | SC | P27 Academy | 2022 | LHP | Miami |
| Sam Falk | NY | Horace Greeley | 2021 | OF | |
| Greg Farone | NY | Schenectady | 2020 | LHP | Alabama |
| Peter Fasciglione | NY | Iona Prep | 2022 | SS | Notre Dame |
| Anthony Febo | NY | Carmel | 2021 | C | Iona |
| Salix Felix | NY | Citius Prep | 2020 | 3B | Dayton |
| Zachary Fike | NY | Medina | 2022 | LHP | Niagara County CC |
| Evan Fisher | NY | Sachem East | 2021 | 1B | Coker College |
| Malachi Flaherty | NY | Guilderland | 2020 | OF | Saint Joseph's College (ME) |
| Michael Flannery | NY | Valley Central | 2020 | LHP | |
| D Mitchell Floccare | NY | St. Josephs Collegiate Institute | 2020 | 2B | Clark University |
| Kyle Flynn | NY | Garden City | 2020 | RHP | Vassar College |
| Sean Foody | NY | Tappan Zee | 2020 | RHP | Franklin Pierce |
| Matthew Franco | NY | Ward Melville | 2020 | OF | |
| Robert Fratangelo | NY | Shaker | 2021 | C | Clarkson University |
| Vincent Fraterrigo | NY | Archbishop Stepinac | 2022 | RHP | |
| Andrew Frobose | NY | Lakeland | 2020 | LHP | |
| Colin Fryling | NY | Williamsville East | 2020 | 3B | Erie CC |
| Jake Fullerton | NY | Walt Whitman | 2020 | RHP | New Jersey Tech |
| Brady Fureno | NY | Fort Plain | 2020 | C | Le Moyne College |
| Thomas Furmanski | NY | Albion | 2020 | RHP | |
| Kyle Gaertner | NY | MacArthur | 2020 | SS | SUNY-New Paltz |
| Joe Gaeta | NY | Fayetteville-Manlius | 2020 | SS | Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Dan Galef | NY | Ossining | 2021 | RHP | Franklin & Marshall College |
| Sam Gallager | NY | West Genesee | 2020 | SS | |
| Ziv Gar | NY | Plainview Old Bethpage | 2020 | RHP | Molloy University |
| Andrew Gault | NY | Lockport | 2020 | 3B | |
| Ethan Gay | NY | Shenendehowa | 2020 | RHP | |
| Michael Geroski | PA | Crestwood | 2020 | C | |
| Joshua Gilkey | NY | East Syracuse-Minoa | 2020 | OF | Onondaga CC |
| Connor Godwin | NY | Horseheads | 2020 | RHP | College of Central FL |
| Kyle Gordon | NY | Trinity-Pawling | 2020 | 3B | Ithaca College |
| Chris Goyette | NY | Medina | 2020 | RHP | SUNY-Cortland |
| Kyle Graff | NY | Lancaster | 2020 | 2B | Alfred State College |
| Nick Grande | NY | Pawling | 2020 | 2B | |
| Jeremy Gross | NY | Suffern | 2021 | 1B | St. Thomas Aquinas College |
| Dominic Guccia | NY | Union-Endicott | 2021 | OF | St. John Fisher College |
| Giorgio Guglielmi | NY | West Genesee | 2020 | RHP | |
| Justin Guiliano | NY | Ellenville | 2020 | LHP | Canisius |
| Adonys Guzman | CT | Brunswick School | 2022 | C | Boston College |
| Stephen Haglund | NY | Yorktown | 2022 | OF | |
| Jonathan Haines | NY | Arkport | 2020 | 1B | Washington & Jefferson College |
| Quinn Hanafin | PA | Sayre Area | 2020 | 3B | Lackawanna JC |
| Carson Harper | NY | Maryvale | 2021 | 2B | Brockport State |
| Logan Haskell | NY | Susquehanna Valley | 2021 | SS | Binghamton |
| Michael Heilig | NY | St. Francis | 2020 | RHP | St. John Fisher College |
| Shane Hewlette | NY | Deer Park | 2020 | OF | Dominican College (NY) |
| Nolan Hicks | NC | Combine Academy | 2021 | SS | Tampa |
| Jerek Hobb | NY | Schalmont | 2022 | LHP | Stony Brook |
| Eric Hodnett | NY | Ballston Spa | 2021 | 1B | Alfred State College |
| Camerin Holmes | NY | North Tonawanda | 2020 | RHP | Niagara County CC |
| Jack Hopko | NY | Maine-Endwell | 2022 | 1B | Rhode Island |
| Brayden Horton | PA | Sayre Area | 2022 | C | Liberty |
| Samuel Howard | NY | Greenwich | 2020 | RHP | Southern New Hampshire University |
| Chris Hudson | NY | Port Chester | 2020 | LHP | |
| William Hudson | NY | Kenmore West | 2020 | RHP | Niagara County CC |
| Troy Hunt | NY | Shaker | 2021 | C | Herkimer County CC |
| Evan Hunter | NY | Croton-Harmon | 2020 | SS | Middlebury College |
| Russell Hunter | NY | Kennedy Catholic | 2022 | 3B | Hofstra |
| Nick Ianniello | NY | Penfield | 2021 | 3B | Brockport State |
| Michael Ippolito | NJ | Randolph | 2020 | SS | North Carolina Central |
| Brent Isaacs | NY | Union-Endicott | 2021 | SS | SUNY-Oneonta |
| Jarred Jackette | NY | Iona Prep | 2022 | OF | St. Peters |
| Owen Jaquette | NY | Bronxville | 2020 | RHP | Drew University |
| Tyler Jennings | NY | Liverpool | 2020 | 1B | Onondaga CC |
| Christian Johnson | CT | Immaculate | 2021 | RHP | |
| Henry Juan | NY | Horseheads | 2020 | C | Williams College |
| Matthew Jung | NY | Maple Hill | 2021 | RHP | Virginia Wesleyan University |
| Matthew Kahn | NY | Archbishop Stepinac | 2020 | RHP | Siena |
| Teddy Kalogris | NY | Arlington | 2020 | 2B | |
| Brady Karp | NY | Byram Hills | 2021 | SS | Bucknell |
| Jimmy Keenan | NY | Iona Prep | 2022 | C | St. John's |
| Jacob Kelly | NY | Hannibal | 2020 | RHP | Wells College |
| Sean Kelly | NY | South Side | 2020 | LHP | Ithaca College |
| Brendan Kenneally | NY | Kennedy Catholic | 2022 | RHP | Adelphi University |
| Michael Kennedy | NY | Troy | 2022 | LHP | Louisiana State |
| Tyler Kensey | NY | West Genesee | 2020 | RHP | SUNY-Cortland |
| Aaron Kifer | NY | Niagara Falls | 2021 | RHP | |
| Nathaniel Kilburn | NY | CBA-Albany | 2020 | RHP | |
| Will Kindl | NY | Burnt Hills-Ballston Lake | 2020 | LHP | St. Thomas Aquinas College |
| Zach Konopka | NY | CBA-Albany | 2020 | RHP | Susquehanna University |
| Thomas Krill | NY | Shenendehowa | 2020 | 1B | College of Saint Rose |
| Jacob LaDuca | NY | Canisius | 2021 | SS | Washington & Jefferson College |
| Jacob LaFountain | NY | Mechanicville | 2020 | RHP | SUNY-Cortland |
| Jacob Lanser | NY | Wallkill | 2022 | LHP | |
| Ryan Lansing | NY | Cooperstown | 2020 | SS | Herkimer County CC |
| Jake Lanzer | NY | Newburgh Free Academy | 2022 | LHP | St. John's |
| Jacob Lapham | NY | Lansingburgh | 2020 | RHP | Hudson Valley CC |
| Anthony Lapine | NY | Liverpool | 2021 | SS | Brockport State |
| Jack Laughlin | NY | Walter Panas | 2021 | RHP | SUNY - Cobleskill |
| Derrick Lewis | NY | Odessa-Montour | 2020 | C | |
| Richie Lewis | NY | Elmira | 2020 | LHP | |
| Adam Liberti | NY | Niagara-Wheatfield | 2020 | 1B | |
| Jonathan Link | NY | Trinity Pawling | 2021 | LHP | Trinity College (CT) |
| Derek Livingston | NY | Paul D. Schreiber | 2020 | RHP | Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute |
| Jake Lombardi | NY | Division Avenue | 2020 | RHP | Herkimer County CC |
| Michael Lombardi | NY | Fox Lane | 2022 | SS | Tulane |
| Hunter Loomis | PA | Warren Area | 2020 | C | Niagara County CC |
| Riley Loomis | NY | Horseheads | 2022 | OF | Niagara County CC |
| Max Luke | GA | North Gwinnett | 2020 | 1B | Georgia Highlands JC |
| Sean Lynch | NY | Monroe Woodbury | 2020 | C | St. Thomas Aquinas College |
| Will MacFarlane | NY | Fairport | 2020 | 1B | |
| Dylan Mackenzie | NY | Canandaigua Academy | 2020 | 3B | SUNY-Cortland |
| Michael Mancini | NY | Maine-Endwell | 2022 | SS | James Madison |
| Robert Manetta | NY | Farmingdale | 2020 | C | Albany |
| AJ Manicchio | NY | Ossining | 2020 | OF | SUNY-Cortland |
| Matthew Mariano | NY | Shenendehowa | 2021 | RHP | Albany |
| Vincent Mariella | NY | Mahopac | 2021 | 1B | Susquehanna University |
| Adam Marsh | NY | Liverpool | 2021 | OF | Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Scott Marsh Jr | NY | Our Lady of Lourdes | 2020 | OF | Keystone College |
| Liam Martin | NY | Loyola School | 2021 | RHP | |
| Cameron May | PA | Delaware Valley | 2021 | C | SUNY-Oneonta |
| Corey May | PA | Delaware Valley | 2022 | C | Mitchell College |
| Sam May | NY | Fulton | 2021 | 2B | |
| Christopher Mazza | NY | Archbishop Molloy | 2020 | RHP | Quinnipiac |
| William McCarthy | NY | Farmingdale | 2020 | RHP | Southern Connecticut State University |
| Brian McCloskey | NY | Seaford | 2020 | SS | |
| Chris McGuggart | NY | Bethpage | 2020 | SS | New York Tech |
| Patrick McGuire | NY | Shenendehowa | 2020 | OF | St. John Fisher College |
| Matthew McHale | NY | Arkport | 2020 | OF | |
| Trevor Mcilroy | NY | Williamsville East | 2020 | OF | |
| Daniel McKenna | NY | Iona Prep | 2021 | C | |
| Chris McKeon | NY | Mahopac | 2022 | RHP | Siena |
| Harry McTernan | NY | Jamesville-Dewitt | 2020 | RHP | |
| Philip Menist | NY | Great Neck South | 2020 | LHP | |
| Dylan Mercedes | NY | Citius Prep | 2019 | 1B | Mansfield University |
| Michael Messina | NY | Marlboro | 2021 | 2B | |
| Sean Meth | NY | Paul D. Schrieber | 2020 | 3B | Trinity College (CT) |
| Cody Miller | NY | Rocky Point | 2022 | SS | East Tennessee State |
| Joshua Milleville | NY | Starpoint | 2021 | RHP | Niagara County CC |
| Jace Miner | PA | Brookville | 2021 | LHP | Wichita State |
| Josh Mollo | NY | Union Endicott | 2020 | SS | |
| Alex Morse | NY | Burnt Hills Ballston Lake | 2020 | SS | American International |
| Timothy Mott | NY | Holy Trinity | 2020 | OF | |
| Andrew Moy | NY | Manhasset | 2021 | RHP | Swarthmore College |
| Nick Mulvey | NY | Westlake | 2021 | LHP | Bucknell |
| Kevin Murphy | NY | Oceanside | 2020 | OF | |
| Roderick Murphy | NY | West Genesee | 2020 | C | |
| Alexander Murray | NY | Weedsport | 2020 | 2B | |
| James Murray | NY | Westlake | 2021 | RHP | Scranton |
| Keito Muto | KY | Clarence | 2020 | OF | Lincoln Trail JC |
| Brett Myers | NY | Lowville Academy | 2020 | SS | Gardner-Webb |
| Justin Nameth | NY | Arlington | 2020 | RHP | SUNY-Oneonta |
| Luke Nascimento | NY | Iona Prep | 2023 | C | Bucknell |
| Ryan Nascimento | NY | Iona Prep | 2020 | C | |
| Nicholas Nealon | NY | Brockport | 2020 | 1B | Niagara County CC |
| Brett Newcomb | NJ | Cedar Grove | 2020 | RHP | Dominican College (NY) |
| Kyle Novak | NY | Arlington | 2021 | 2B | SUNY-Cortland |
| Jagger Nucci | NY | Greece Athena | 2020 | SS | St. Bonaventure |
| Brian O'Boyle | NY | Bethpage | 2020 | SS | Long Island |
| Charlie O'Brien | NY | Chaminade | 2020 | C | Hamilton College |
| Daniel O'Byrne | NY | Fordham Prep | 2020 | OF | |
| Jack O'Connor | NY | Mahopac | 2021 | SS | SUNY-Oneonta |
| Nick OConnor | NY | Wantagh | 2020 | SS | St. Thomas Aquinas College |
| Max Odum | NY | Elmira | 2020 | 2B | Wells College |
| Zack Odum | NY | Elmira | 2020 | OF | Wells College |
| Aiden Oliver | PA | Delaware Valley | 2021 | RHP | |
| Brandon Ortiz | NY | Warwick | 2020 | SS | Binghamton |
| Justin Osborn | NY | Shaker | 2020 | 1B | St. John Fisher College |
| Nathan Owens | NY | Waterville | 2021 | 1B | |
| Luke Padian | NY | Fordham Prep | 2020 | 1B | Amherst College |
| Jaime C. Padilla | NY | Archbishop Stepinac | 2022 | C | Shenandoah University |
| Ryan Paige | NY | West Genesee | 2020 | RHP | |
| Richard Paltridge | NY | John S. Burke Catholic | 2020 | LHP | Penn State |
| Pavlos Papoutsakis | NY | W.T. Clarke | 2020 | 1B | Dominican College (NY) |
| Nick Pappas | NY | Carmel | 2021 | RHP | Massachusetts-Dartmouth |
| Thomas Parisi | NY | Somers | 2020 | OF | Union College (NY) |
| Max Parker | NY | Fayetteville-Manlius | 2020 | LHP | Le Moyne College |
| Zach Parker | NY | Williamsville North | 2020 | C | Erie CC |
| Wyatt Parliament | NY | LaFargeville | 2022 | RHP | Virginia Tech |
| Nick Partsch | NY | Iroquois | 2020 | RHP | Siena |
| Daniel Pascali | NY | Massapequa | 2020 | C | SUNY-Old Westbury |
| Mitchell Pascarella | NY | Southwestern | 2020 | RHP | Connecticut |
| Michael Pastrana | FL | TNXL Academy | 2024 | RHP | |
| Justin Patsey | NY | FDR | 2020 | SS | SUNY-Cortland |
| Richie Paul | NY | Camden | 2020 | RHP | SUNY-Oswego |
| Alvin Paulino | NY | St. Raymond HS for Boys | 2021 | C | |
| Antonio Pena | NY | Bishop Loughlin | 2021 | SS | Dominican College (NY) |
| Gabriel Perez | NY | Arlington | 2020 | SS | SUNY-Oneonta |
| Mark Perez II | NY | Walter Panas | 2020 | SS | Westchester CC |
| Mario Pesca | NY | Cardinal Spellman | 2022 | RHP | Oklahoma State |
| Corey Phelan | NY | Harborfields | 2020 | OF | Flagler College |
| Jay Pichardo | SC | P27 Academy | 2022 | OF | |
| Philip Piro | NY | Lynbrook | 2020 | LHP | Concordia College (NY) |
| Chase Playfair | NY | Penfield | 2022 | RHP | St. Bonaventure |
| Thomas Plunkett | NY | Mamaroneck | 2020 | RHP | Scranton |
| Matthew Procopio | NY | Horseheads | 2022 | SS | Niagara County CC |
| Lucas Prokosch | NY | Newburgh Free Academy | 2020 | RHP | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Nicholas Provenzale | NY | Pittsford Sutherland | 2021 | RHP | |
| Tyler Pugliese | NY | Yorktown | 2021 | C | Albany |
| Brody Raleigh | NC | Christ School | 2023 | 2B | Western Carolina |
| Jordan Ramlogan | NY | Holy Trinity | 2020 | 2B | Queens College |
| Miguel Ramos JR. | NY | Monroe-Woodbury | 2021 | RHP | Plattsburgh State University of New York |
| Nathan Ray | NY | Baldwinsville | 2023 | C | Ithaca College |
| Bryce Reimer | NY | Sullivan West | 2020 | LHP | Bucknell |
| Brian Reinke | NY | Honeoye Falls Lima | 2021 | LHP | Richmond |
| Jake Repaci | NY | Trinity Pawling | 2020 | OF | Union College (NY) |
| Isaac Reyes | NY | East Islip | 2020 | OF | SUNY-Purchase |
| Michael Rocas | NY | Amsterdam | 2020 | C | |
| Justine Rodriguez | NY | George Washington | 2021 | RHP | Florida International |
| Keldrin Rodriguez | NY | Valley Central | 2023 | OF | Monroe College |
| Luis Rodriguez | NY | James Monroe | 2020 | 3B | Western Oklahoma State JC |
| Luca Romano | NY | Shoreham-Wading River | 2020 | RHP | |
| Shawn Romanowski | NY | Sweet Home | 2020 | C | Hilbert College |
| Tyler Rosenberg | NY | Horace Greeley | 2020 | LHP | |
| Chris Rowan | NY | Canisius | 2020 | OF | |
| Domenic Rowlands | VA | Jefferson Forest | 2021 | RHP | King University |
| Keegan Rude | PA | Athens Area | 2020 | RHP | Northampton CC |
| Trenton Rumley | NY | St Mary's | 2021 | SS | Canisius |
| Conner Rush | NY | Maine-Endwell | 2021 | C | Franklin & Marshall College |
| Josh Russo | NY | Ward Melville | 2021 | 1B | SUNY-Cortland |
| Joseph Salata | NY | Clarke | 2020 | RHP | |
| Jacob Sanders | NY | Auburn | 2020 | RHP | SUNY-Oswego |
| Cullen SantaMaria | NY | Shoreham Wading River | 2020 | RHP | Hofstra |
| Jackson Sattinger | NY | Paul D. Schreiber | 2020 | OF | Hamilton College |
| Corey Savedoff | NY | Clarkstown North | 2021 | RHP | Rhode Island |
| Matthew Savedoff | NY | Clarkstown North | 2021 | SS | Johns Hopkins University |
| Scott Scheppy | NY | Newburgh Free Academy | 2021 | RHP | Mercy University |
| Max Schmarder | NY | Olmsted | 2020 | C | Monroe Community College |
| Derek Schumaker | NY | Paul V. Moore | 2021 | C | |
| Jared Sciarrino | NY | Shoreham-Wading River | 2020 | OF | St. Thomas Aquinas College |
| Ryan Scott | NY | Horseheads | 2021 | 2B | Mansfield University |
| Cole Sebastian | PA | Otto-Eldred | 2021 | OF | Canisius |
| Jason Sebastiano | NY | St. Edmund Preparatory | 2020 | 3B | SUNY-Purchase |
| Brendan Seburn | NY | East Syracuse-Minoa | 2020 | 3B | Brockport State |
| Nick Selden | NY | Trinity-Pawling | 2020 | RHP | Denison University |
| Jose Silva III | NY | Monsignor McClancy | 2020 | OF | Tampa |
| Michael Sirota | CT | The Gunnery | 2021 | OF | Northeastern |
| Sterling Sisson | NY | CRCS | 2020 | RHP | |
| Aaron Sisto | NY | Liverpool | 2020 | 3B | Delaware State |
| Chris Sleeper | NY | Rush Henrietta | 2021 | RHP | West Virginia |
| Kennen Smith | NY | Arlington | 2020 | RHP | Le Moyne College |
| Zachary Smith | NY | Fayetteville- Manlius | 2020 | 2B | |
| Noah Sorensen | PA | Scranton Preparatory | 2022 | SS | Connecticut |
| Itai Spinoza | NY | Fayetteville-Manlius | 2021 | LHP | Elon |
| Garrett Srock | NY | Newfane | 2020 | RHP | Niagara County CC |
| Drew Stabinsky | NY | Floral Park | 2020 | RHP | SUNY-Purchase |
| James Staedt | NY | Frontier | 2020 | RHP | Penn State University-Harrisburg |
| Michael Stellrecht | NY | Williamsville East | 2022 | SS | Binghamton |
| Nicholas Stevens | NY | Liverpool | 2021 | C | Onondaga CC |
| Andrew Stillinger | NY | Niagara-Wheatfield | 2021 | SS | Niagara County CC |
| Massimo Stinziani | NY | Pleasantville | 2021 | C | |
| Jacek Strain | NY | Shenendehowa | 2021 | C | Plattsburgh State University of New York |
| Jackson Strong | NY | West Seneca East | 2021 | OF | Canisius |
| Howard Stuckey | NY | Salamanca | 2020 | RHP | |
| Christopher Suero | NY | All Hallows | 2022 | OF | |
| Billy Sullivan | NY | Chaminade | 2020 | SS | Clark University |
| Jack Sullivan | NY | Carmel | 2021 | RHP | Connecticut |
| Kenneth Svitak | NY | Baldwinsville | 2021 | OF | D'Youville College |
| Justin Swavely | NY | Rome Free Academy | 2020 | RHP | Brockport State |
| Jeffrey Swift | NY | Shenendehowa | 2020 | C | Springfield College |
| Ryan Taffe | NY | Bethlehem | 2022 | RHP | Fairfield |
| Zach Taro | NY | Susquehanna Valley | 2020 | 3B | SUNY-Cortland |
| Bryan Taveras | NY | John S. Burke Catholic | 2020 | RHP | Alvernia University |
| Zander Teator | NY | Saratoga Springs | 2022 | SS | Babson College |
| Matthew Tiberia | NY | CBA - Albany | 2020 | 3B | College of Saint Rose |
| Brendan Tierney | NY | Trinity-Pawling | 2021 | OF | |
| Dylan Tierney | NY | Columbia | 2021 | SS | SUNY-Cortland |
| Brian Tietjen | NY | Guilderland | 2020 | 1B | Brockport State |
| Daniel Tirabassi | NY | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | 3B | Rochester |
| Joe Tobia | NY | St Joseph's Collegiate Institute | 2021 | RHP | Albany |
| Daniel Tocco | NY | Canisius | 2020 | 3B | |
| Matt Tringali | NY | Connequot | 2020 | 1B | St. John Fisher College |
| Christopher Ubner | NY | Cooperstown | 2021 | 3B | St. Thomas Aquinas College |
| Julian Uejima | NY | Trinity-Pawling | 2020 | SS | Quinnipiac |
| Alex Ungar | NY | Connetquot | 2020 | 3B | Albany |
| Diego Urreta | NY | The Harvey | 2021 | SS | Monroe College |
| Matt Vaccaro | NY | Fayetteville-Manlius | 2020 | OF | Keuka College |
| Nick Valdes | NY | Fordham Prep | 2020 | 2B | |
| Ryan VanDeWater | NY | Our Lady of Lourdes | 2022 | RHP | Connecticut |
| Nicholas Vega | NY | Trinity Pawling | 2022 | OF | New Jersey Tech |
| Thomas Verga | NY | William Floyd | 2020 | 3B | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Austin Wainer | GA | Johns Creek | 2020 | RHP | Bryant |
| Aidan Wallace | NY | Clarence | 2020 | OF | Ithaca College |
| Aedan Walter | PA | Delaware Valley | 2020 | RHP | Lock Haven University |
| Patrick Walters | NY | Shaker | 2020 | 3B | |
| Jadon Wanat | NY | Williamsville North | 2024 | OF | Monroe Community College |
| Jaden Waterman | VA | Virginia Episcopal | 2021 | 3B | |
| Owen Wendell-Braly | NY | Millbrook Prep | 2021 | RHP | Southern California |
| Elliot Widenor | NY | St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute | 2020 | LHP | Canisius |
| Jovani Wiggs | NY | Shaker | 2021 | OF | Herkimer County CC |
| Joseph Wike | NY | Bishop Grimes | 2020 | 2B | |
| Logan Wing | NY | Jamesville-Dewitt | 2020 | SS | Brockport State |
| Orin Winslow | NJ | Ramsey | 2020 | RHP | St. Thomas Aquinas College |
| Carter Wisely | NY | Cicero-North Syracuse | 2020 | LHP | Southern New Hampshire University |
| Cole Zaffiro | NY | Manhasset | 2020 | RHP | Pennsylvania |
| Nick Zigrosser | NY | Bethlehem Central | 2020 | C | |
| Seth Zurbruegg | NY | Jamesville-Dewitt | 2020 | RHP |