Prep Baseball Report

2025 MLB Draft Board: May Update


By Prep Baseball Draft HQ

As the spring season winds down and the scouting heat turns up, Prep Baseball’s Draft Board 3.0 arrives with more clarity, conviction, and a few key shakeups.

The class continues to evolve as players rise, fall, and solidify their cases with every pitch thrown and barrel found. With data flowing in and live looks stacking up, it’s becoming increasingly clear who’s trending toward the top – and who still has something to prove. This is not just a ranking – this is a roadmap of projection, present tools, and future big league impact. From the elite prep arms to the on-the-rise bats that keep performing against high-level competition, this board reflects what decision-makers are watching closely. With July looming, draft boards are getting tighter, and 3.0 brings the sharpest version yet.

Before we get going here's some more big boards to be aware of that dive deeper into this class as a whole:


DRAFT HQ HEADLINES

+ SHORTSTOPS!

Of the players ranked inside the top-20, 11 are listed as shortstops, and both No. 10-ranked Xavier Neyens (Mt. Vernon HS, WA; Oregon State commit) and No. 13 Gavin Kilen (Tennessee; Milton HS, WI, 2022) are potentially set to be sent off at that position professionally. More specifically, the prep group boasts the potential for 10 shortstops to go in the first round with even more going in the first 50 picks. Even beyond those who opt to sign professional contracts after this year’s draft, the group of premium positioned prospects extends much further, and the culminating balance of first-rounders from this bunch (between the 2025-2028 drafts) is likely to approach 20 from this star-studded group of 2025 high school graduates.

+ Injury Value

Each draft year brings with it a host of injuries to pitchers that disrupt the natural scouting cycle and presents much less time for the mitigation of risk. Prep RHP Marcos Paz (Hebron HS, TX; LSU) still ranks No. 9 among right-handed pitchers in the prep class, even without having thrown an inning this spring. Surgery after a dominant junior campaign disrupted his case in challenging top-ranked RHP Seth Hernandez (Corona HS, CA; Vanderbilt) as the No. 1 prep arm in the class, but his track record and return to bullpens (post-spring) more than warrants Day One consideration with intrinsic value.

Marcos Paz (2/14/24)

+ DAY ONE INTRIGUE

If you are looking for which teams to watch closely on the first day of the MLB Draft, narrow your focus to the number of picks these teams are holstering on day one: Orioles (6), Rays (6), Brewers (5), and Guardians (5). Each has a significant number of picks, and even more notably, these are teams that have exhibited the propensity to stretch their dollars to acquire quality talent via quantity. With money to spend for these strong scouting departments, the possibility of prospects with first-round grades signing for over slot later on in the draft becomes more likely.


KEY RISERS

+ No. 79 ➡️ 36: Josh Owens (TN)

A breakout, must-follow name from the summer circuit, SS Josh Owens’ (Providence Academy HS, TN; Georgia Southern) dynamic ability as a left-handed stick, low-slit/loose-armed right-handed arm, and all-around versatile defender propelled his stock into the top-100 in the class last fall. However, his athletic play at shortstop with soft, confident hands and a strong arm, this spring, along with a projectable 6-foot-3, 185-pound frame that has received a boost of strength and power outputs, has elevated his stock. Similar to the hushed excitement that fellow Volunteer State native, Evan Carter, received in the atypical 2020 MLB Draft, Owens has almost hid in the shadows of regional risers like JoJo Parker, Steele Hall, and Daniel Pierce. His bat-to-ball ability from the left side stands out, along with the impressive athleticism, and the frame should see significant advancements in coming years in helping to envision a hit/power profile that might stick at shortstop long term. While the aforementioned trio are likely to go ahead, the club who ultimately picks Owens is sure to be giddy about his future impact.

Josh Owens (5/1/25)


+ No. 159 ➡️ 50: Frank Cairone (NJ)

In what has become a packed lineup of southpaws in the prep class, LHP Frank Cairone (Delsea HS, NJ; Coastal Carolina) has steadily elevated his stock since announcing himself with a clean showing at the Super 60 in February. Climbing up to 96 mph this spring, his 3000+ rpm breaking ball has shined along with a silky smooth arm stroke to help deliver 72K-13BB in 33 innings pitched thus far. Beyond the stellar postings from the Coastal Carolina recruit, the idea that he may have even more untapped potential is what is sure to drive Day 1 suitors to the table, and that notion is more than warranted when compared to the rest of the class.

Frank Cairone (Super 60; 2/2/25)


+ No. 26 ➡️ 11: SS JoJo Parker (Purvis HS, MS)
+ No. 45 ➡️ 12: SS Steele Hall (Hewitt Trussville HS, AL)
+ No. 61 ➡️ 23: SS Daniel Pierce (Mill Creek HS, GA)
+ No. 67 ➡️ 41: RHP Dean Livingston (Hebron Christian Academy, GA)
+ No. 93 ➡️ 70: LHP Talon Haley (Lewisburg HS, MS)


NEW PREP FACES

+ No. 78: Jayden Stroman (NY)

RHP/SS Jayden Stroman’s (Patchogue-Medford HS, NY; Duke) explosive arm talent and dynamic athleticism have driven his stock higher and higher throughout the spring. Routinely working into the upper 90s with the fastball, his swing-and-miss arsenal includes a firm, wipeout slider, and the advanced movement patterns provide ample reason to believe that he can continue as a starter.

(Northeast ProCase; 2/8/25)


+ No. 142: Michael Oliveto (NY)

C Michael Oliveto (Hauppauge HS, NY; Yale) presents one of the more intriguing draft profiles in the class as an inbound Ivy Leaguer, but his quality left-handed stroke has had the scouting community, and decision-makers, heading east on the Long Island Expressway for multiple looks. Wiry-athletic at 6-foot-3, with room to add significant strength, his firm outputs and bat-to-ball ability is ultra intriguing.

(Northeast ProCase; 2/8/25)


+ No. 149: Matt McKnight (NC)

A presumptive “future push” coming away from the Super 60 in February, 3B Matt McKnight’s (Charlotte Catholic HS, NC; North Carolina) strong spring has driven more intrigue as to the immediacy of his professional potential. At 6-foot-3, 192-pounds with a fluid, controlled right-handed stroke, the power outputs have ticked up, some, and the upward trajectory of his hit/power profile could ultimately provide an avenue to buy out his Chapel Hill residency in blossoming as the next Tar Heel talent who excels on campus.

(Super 60; 2/2/25)


+ No. 150: Timothy Piasentin (AB, Canada)

As Canadian prospects continue to make loud statements at all levels, the combing for draft value continues in ‘25, and 3B Timothy Piasentin (Foothills Composite, AB; Miami) is a physical left-handed stick that could hear his name called on Day Two. The 6-foot-3, 205-pounder carries a power profile with the ability to lift, and has trended up with some big performances this spring.

(5/5/25)


DRAFT HQ: TOP-100

Rank
Player
Pos.
School
1 Ethan Holliday SS Stillwater HS (OK)
2 Seth Hernandez RHP Corona HS (CA)
3 Jamie Arnold LHP Florida State
4 Kade Anderson* LHP LSU
5 Cameron Appenzeller LHP Glenwood HS (IL)
6 Kayson Cunningham SS S.A. Johnson HS (TX)
7 Billy Carlson SS Corona HS (CA)
8 Josh Hammond SS Wesleyan Christian HS (NC)
9 Eli Willits SS Fort Cobb-Broxton HS (OK)
10 Xavier Neyens 3B Mount Vernon HS (WA)
11 Aiva Arquette SS Oregon State
12 Brayden Jaksa C Irvington HS (CA)
13 Gavin Kilen SS Tennessee
14 Marek Houston SS Wake Forest
15 Wehiwa Aloy SS Arkansas
16 Kyson Witherspoon RHP Oklahoma
17 Liam Doyle LHP Tennessee
18 Brady Ebel SS Corona HS (CA)
19 Joseph Parker SS Purvis HS (MS)
20 Steele Hall SS Hewitt-Trussville HS (AL)
21 Jaden Fauske OF Nazareth Academy HS (IL)
22 Brendan Summerhill OF Arizona
23 Devin Taylor OF Indiana
24 Ike Irish C Auburn
25 Tyler Bremner RHP UC Santa Barbara
26 Alex Lodise SS Florida State
27 Jace LaViolette OF Texas A&M
28 Jack Bauer LHP Lincoln-Way East HS (IL)
29 Kruz Schoolcraft LHP Sunset HS (OR)
30 Caleb Barnett 3B Mountain Brook HS (AL)
31 Johnny Slawinski III LHP Johnson City HS (TX)
32 Briggs McKenzie LHP Corinth Holders HS (NC)
33 Angel Cervantes RHP Warren HS (CA)
34 Ty Peeples OF Franklin County HS (GA)
35 Nicky Becker SS Don Bosco Prep HS (NJ)
36 Coy James SS Davie HS (NC)
37 Daniel Pierce SS Mill Creek HS (GA)
38 Gavin Fien 3B Great Oak HS (CA)
39 Luke Stevenson* C North Carolina
40 Ethan Conrad OF Wake Forest
41 Anthony Eyanson RHP LSU
42 Riley Quick RHP Alabama
43 Marcus Phillips RHP Tennessee
44 Matthew Fisher RHP Evansville Memorial HS (IN)
45 Quentin Young 3B Oaks Christian HS (CA)
46 Slater de Brun OF Summit HS (OR)
47 Lucas Franco 3B Cinco Ranch HS (TX)
48 Sean Gamble UTL IMG Academy HS (FL)
49 Jacob Parker OF Purvis HS (MS)
50 Caden Bodine C Coastal Carolina
51 Zach Root LHP Arkansas
52 Andrew Fischer 1B Tennessee
53 Dean Curley* 3B Tennessee
54 Gage Wood RHP Arkansas
55 Ethan Petry OF South Carolina
56 Aidan West SS Long Reach HS (MD)
57 Landon Harmon RHP East Union HS (MS)
58 CJ Gray RHP A.L. Brown HS (NC)
59 Max Belyeu OF Texas
60 Reid Worley RHP Cherokee HS (GA)
61 Boston Kellner 3B Hamilton HS (AZ)
62 Josh Owens SS Providence Academy HS (TN)
63 Aaron Watson RHP Trinity Christian HS (FL)
64 AJ Russell RHP Tennessee
65 Patrick Forbes RHP Louisville
66 Taitn Gray OF Dallas Center-Grimes HS (IA)
67 Uli Fernsler LHP Novi HS (MI)
68 JD Thompson LHP Vanderbilt
69 Cam Cannarella OF Clemson
70 Danny Dickinson 2B LSU
71 Kyle Lodise SS Georgia Tech
72 Korbyn Dickerson OF Indiana
73 Joseph Dzierwa LHP Michigan State
74 Marcos Paz RHP Hebron HS (TX)
75 Dean Livingston RHP Hebron Christian HS (GA)
76 Brandon Logan OF Fort Wayne Snider HS (IN)
77 Tate Southisene SS Basic Academy HS (NV)
78 Blaine Bullard OF Klein Cain HS (TX)
79 Pico Kohn LHP Mississippi State
80 Omar Serna C Lutheran South HS (TX)
81 Colby Shelton SS Florida
82 River Hamilton RHP Sam Barlow HS (OR)
83 John Stuetzer OF Pope HS (GA)
84 Caden Crowell LHP Valparaiso HS (IN)
85 Henry Godbout 2B Virginia
86 Alec Blair OF De La Salle HS (CA)
87 Henry Ford* OF Virginia
88 Frank Cairone LHP Delsea HS (NJ)
89 Mitch Voit 2B Michigan
90 Charles Davalan* OF Arkansas
91 JB Middleton RHP Southern Miss
92 James Ellwanger* RHP Dallas Baptist
93 Nick Dumesnil OF Cal Baptist
94 Gavin Turley OF Oregon State
95 Nic Partridge SS Mulberry HS (FL)
96 Dean Moss OF IMG Academy HS (FL)
97 Max Williams OF Florida State
98 Mason Neville OF Oregon
99 Kane Kepley OF North Carolina
100 Jordan Martin RHP Jefferson City HS (MO)

*Indicates the player is a college sophomore who's age-eligible for the 2025 MLB Draft.


RELATED CONTENT