NY Class of 2025 Rankings (Spring Update)
April 4, 2025
Prep Baseball New York recently wrapped up a whirlwind of a preseason. Getting eyes on over 1,000 players throughout the Empire State. Now those players are competing for their high school baseball programs, and trying to make a run at the State Championship. This is a perfect time to sit down, and take a deep dive into the 2025 rankings. A few big jumps within the class after big showings at The Prep Baseball Super 60 and our Northeast ProCase this past February. Others continued to raise their stock throughout the offseason and have carried it into the start of the high school season. We take an indepth look at the Top 10, the top stories of the offseason, and the full rankings below!
Full Rankings: HERE
Follow The Team
Follow @DanCevette Follow @ocker_n Follow @JC_NY_PA Follow @JoeWalentin
 |
Justice de Jong RHP / 3B / Poly Prep, NY / 2025
|
 |
Miguel Sime RHP / OF / Poly Prep, NY / 2025
|
 |
Jordan Serrano OF / The Stony Brook School, NY / 2025
|
 |
Jayden Stroman SS / RHP / Patchogue-Medford, NY / 2025Rankings StateRank: 4 / POS: 1
|
 |
Erick Peralta RHP / Grand Street Campus, NY / 2025
|
 |
Nicholas Frusco LHP / 1B / MILLER PLACE HIGH SCHOOL, NY / 2025Rankings StateRank: 6 / POS: 1
|
 |
Michael Oliveto C / 3B / Hauppauge, NY / 2025Rankings StateRank: 7 / POS: 1
|
 |
Mateo Noto SS / 2B / Poly Prep , NY / 2025Rankings StateRank: 8 / POS: 2
|
 |
Thomas Case RHP / 3B / Shaker, NY / 2025Rankings StateRank: 9 / POS: 4
|
 |
Sebastian Santos-Olson LHP / 1B / The Stony Brook School, NY / 2025Rankings StateRank: 10 / POS: 2
|
TOP UNCOMMITTED
Sub 7 runner with a 96 MPH OF arm!
2025 OF Luis Garcia (James Monroe Campus, NY); 6-2, 208 lbs.
— Prep Baseball New York (@PrepBaseballNY) June 5, 2024
Controlled, calm approach with quick hands and big pop to all fields.
Exit Velo: 99mph 🚀 @5_TPDevelopment pic.twitter.com/NoCM6NJh1c
𝐌𝐕𝐏 𝐒𝐜𝐨𝐮𝐭 𝐃𝐚𝐲
— Prep Baseball New York (@PrepBaseballNY) June 5, 2024
‘25 LHP Joseph Vetrano (St. Francis Prep) 6-0, 185LB southpaw creeps towards 3000 RPM on his SL. Lower IVB FB has some firm and late arm side sink. Ridiculously high spin breaker shows late 2-tier break.
FB: 83-84 T85 (2245🔄 13IVB, 15HM↙️)
SL: 75-77… pic.twitter.com/iwyMd39bRJ
Impressive all around day from ‘25 OF/RHP Willy Pineda (Progress HS for Professional Careers) 5-10, 167 lb ⚡️Athlete
— Joe Walentin (@JoeWalentin) February 22, 2025
Exit Velo: max 99.9 MPH, Avg 91 MPH@TrackManBB
Bat Sp: max 79.2, Avg 73.5 MPH
Rot. Acc: max 48.3g, Avg 40g💥
On Plane%: max 78, Avg 74 @Blast_Bsbl
FB: max 91… pic.twitter.com/zfJwsmpZ2b
▪️@PBR_Uncommitted 𝐒𝐩𝐨𝐭𝐥𝐢𝐠𝐡𝐭🔦
— Prep Baseball New York (@PrepBaseballNY) October 23, 2024
👤‘25 SS/RHP Oneal Polanco @oneal_polanco
🏫 Gregorio Luperon
📓Athletic w/ plenty of tools. Rangy defender w/ a rocket arm. Compact swing, easy pull side juice‼️
🔹60 time- 6.96
🔹EV- 92.4mph
🔹INF Velo- 88mph
📝⤵️
🖇️:… pic.twitter.com/JpJhX5AZgU
High spin electric stuff from the strong right hander
♨️The Hotlist: Preseason Breakout Candidates♨️
— Prep Baseball (@prepbaseball) January 19, 2024
'25 RHP Rhys Carway (NY): The end of October showed Carway's on the rise as he added six mph to his fastball since March to complement a high spin slider. @DanCevette @PBRNewYork
🔗 https://t.co/5ceKaDaq5y | @ShooterHunt pic.twitter.com/gfNuFItRMt
2025 MIF Myles Monell (Citius Prep) 6-foot-1, 180 lb. Premium defender with lateral range and a strong, accurate arm. Efficient timing mechanism at the plate with strong rotation; pop continues to develop w/ G2G, LD approach
— Prep Baseball New York (@PrepBaseballNY) October 10, 2023
60⏱️ 7.01
INF 💪 86 MPH
Exit Velo: 93 MPH💥
Bat Speed:… pic.twitter.com/Cvzyr77AcS