2025 VA/DC High School All-State: Underclass

June 23, 2025
Staff
Prep Baseball Virginia/DC

Follow @PrepBaseballVA
Facebook + Instagram

This week we will highlight some of the top performers from the 2025 high school season. We will have five different All-State teams that we will unveil, starting with the Underclass Team which is made up of all 2027-2028 graduates.

*Please note, stats MUST have been submitted in order for a player to be considered for an All-State team.*

*Stats below reflect what was submitted prior to the June 9th deadline.*

Pitchers

Justin Bischoff RHP / 3B / Freeman High, VA / 2027

‘27 Justin Bischoff (@DSF_Baseball)

Has worked 2 quick scoreless innings collecting multiple K’s. Has an advanced feel for the CH. FB works inter and outer half.

FB 83-85 T86
CH 73-75
CB 69-70

Tied 0-0 after 2 innings #VHSLRegion5C pic.twitter.com/H345A9W86z
— Prep Baseball Virginia/DC (@PrepBaseballVA) May 31, 2025

Samuel Critzer RHP / 1B / Randolph-Henry High, VA / 2028

Colby Fesler 2B / SS / Broadway, VA / 2027

‘27 Colby Fesler (@BwayBaseballVA)

A quick two scoreless innings for Fesler. SL has been effective early with whiffs low ITZ. Has worked FB in and out.

FB 81-84
SL 71-74
CT 78@PrepBaseballVA #BeSeen pic.twitter.com/bLjVL7PRnJ
— Prep Baseball VA/DC Scouting (@PrepBaseVAS) April 15, 2025

Noah Lambrinides RHP / OF / HERNDON HIGH, VA / 2027

2027 RHP Noah Lambrinides (@HHornetBaseball)

Low three-quarters slot with a longer arm action. 2-plane action on breaking ball

FB 82-84
CB 71-73#BeSeen @PrepBaseballVA #LibertyDistrict pic.twitter.com/PC5YKgnuY9
— John Nolan (@PBVADC_Nolan) May 20, 2025

Nolan Lamm RHP / OF / William Monroe High, VA / 2027

‘27 Nolan Lamm (@WMHSBaseball643)

Has been ITZ early on. FB velo is down a bit on this cold night. Sitting 82-84 T85. Has featured a CB/SL that have blended shapes, but has shown feel for both. CB 72-74 SL 76-78. Has minimized damage and gotten better as the outing has gone on.… pic.twitter.com/x4OqKVoH8i
— Prep Baseball VA/DC Scouting (@PrepBaseVAS) April 8, 2025

Elijah Marshall LHP / 1B / John Champe HS, VA / 2027

O'Riyan Mosier RHP / OF / Churchland High, VA / 2027

Cole Schaaf LHP / OF / LOUDOUN VALLEY HIGH, VA / 2027

Infielders

Ryan Bahr SS / RHP / ST PAUL VI CATHOLIC HIGH SCHOOL, VA / 2028

‘28 Ryan Bahr goes down and gets this one to send it out of LF for a 2 run 💣. @PVI_Baseball leads 3-0.@VISAABaseball #VISAA2025 pic.twitter.com/jP2rhSeoin
— Prep Baseball Virginia/DC (@PrepBaseballVA) May 18, 2025

Noah Brooks 3B / RHP / Nansemond Suffolk Academy, VA / 2027

Just like that, ‘27 Noah Brooks ties it up for Nansemond-Suffolk.

First pitch swinging for a 2 run 💣 . The sophomore is hitting over .350 on the year.

East Coast Super Sophomore alum@VISAABaseball #VISAA2025 pic.twitter.com/kojwdxsgp5
— Prep Baseball Virginia/DC (@PrepBaseballVA) May 12, 2025

Yogi Colangelo 2B / 2B / Battlefield, VA / 2027

‘27 Yogi Colangelo (@HokiesBaseball) goes back through the middle with this 2K single.

Battlefield trails 5-4 headed to T3. #VHSLRegion6B pic.twitter.com/mC8VNmO2Y2
— Prep Baseball Virginia/DC (@PrepBaseballVA) June 5, 2025

Ethan Foster 2B / SS / Wise Central, VA / 2028

Eli Hulette SS / 2B / JAMES RIVER HIGH, VA / 2027

Graham Hutchens SS / Hampton Roads Academy, VA / 2027

Blake LaMattina SS / RHP / Cosby, VA / 2027

‘27 Blake LaMattina (Cosby)

This one got out in a HURRY! Turns the barrel for a no doubter out of LF.

Physical athlete that has easy 🧃 gap to gap. #2 player in ‘27 VA/DC class.@PrepBaseballVA @ksallday19 @ShooterHunt #BeSeen pic.twitter.com/aUSANSjqit
— Jordan Jones (@JJonesPBVADC) April 18, 2025

Casey Rector 2B / SS / John S. Battle, VA / 2027

Circle this name for the summer circuit, Casey Rector.

The 2027 MIF can defend in the middle and has shown a solid feel for the barrel in our looks. Ambushes the 1st pitch from a reliever for a 💣 out of LCF. @BattleBaseball1 leads 8-5 B2. @34rector @ShooterHunt… pic.twitter.com/7OJPrsgM1h
— Prep Baseball Virginia/DC (@PrepBaseballVA) May 20, 2025

Tiernan Sanders 1B / RHP / Brentsville District, VA / 2028

‘28 Tiernan Sanders (@bdtigerbaseball)

The freshman drops a 3 run no-doubt bomb way out of LF. 💣

Tigers now lead 6-1 in the second. #VHSLRegion3B pic.twitter.com/Cmhksvx3Lw
— Prep Baseball Virginia/DC (@PrepBaseballVA) May 29, 2025

Ethan Wayman RHP / 3B / Christiansburg High, VA / 2027

‘27 Ethan Wayman (@chs_demonball)

2-2 on the day with this RBI 2K single into RF.@PrepBaseballVA #BeSeen pic.twitter.com/l4QJbFtNjT
— Prep Baseball VA/DC Scouting (@PrepBaseVAS) April 15, 2025

Outfielders

Palmer Gobble RHP / John Battle, VA / 2027

‘27 Palmer Gobble turns on this inside pitch for a hard hit single through the right side. @BattleBaseball1 trailing 3-2. #MountainDistrictTourney pic.twitter.com/Il0ZE13URG
— Prep Baseball Virginia/DC (@PrepBaseballVA) May 20, 2025

Noah Gray OF / 2B / MILLER SCHOOL OF ALBEMARLE, VA / 2027

Just another day for ‘27 Noah Gray.

The @MSA_baseball outfielder has really solid bat to ball skills and has showed up consistently in box scores. Aggressive early in counts and looking to hit. Pair of singles on the day. @PrepBaseballVA #BeSeen pic.twitter.com/svzXW1mYZU
— Jason Burton (@ksallday19) March 19, 2025

Michael Guerra OF / RHP / NANSEMOND RIVER HIGH, VA / 2027

‘27 Michael Guerra singles for @NRWarriorsBSB . Had a hard hit lineout to deep LF in first AB.

We are still scoreless in M4 of the first #VHSLRegion5B quarterfinal. #BeSeen pic.twitter.com/gNiWIhyKkI
— Prep Baseball Virginia/DC (@PrepBaseballVA) May 30, 2025

Jaerron Johnson OF / SS / St. Christopher's, VA / 2027

‘27 Jaerron Johnson (St. Christopher’s)

Another barrel for Johnson as he shoots a single into CF for a RBI. #CommonwealthClassic https://t.co/WpCbSzbyRS pic.twitter.com/pwbrFlkVd7
— Prep Baseball Virginia/DC (@PrepBaseballVA) April 12, 2025

Nico Moritz-Toledo OF / 1B / Battlefield, VA / 2027

‘27 Nico Moritz-Toledo #Hokies (@GoBHSBaseball)

Goes with this pitch the other way for a RBI double.

High end run tool that can hit the ball to all fields@ksallday19 @PrepBaseballVA #BeSeen pic.twitter.com/dTSt4ViU9n
— Jordan Jones (@JJonesPBVADC) April 24, 2025

Luke Murphy OF / 1B / Langley, VA / 2027

‘27 Luke Murphy (@LangleyBaseball)

Lanky 6’ frame w/ RTF. Multi hit day for the sophomore LHH. Takes this one back through the middle to extend the Langley lead. @PrepBaseballVA #BeSeen pic.twitter.com/7ftDUUoi1k
— Prep Baseball VA/DC Scouting (@PrepBaseVAS) April 16, 2025

Will Park SS / C / COVENANT, VA / 2027

Jackson Plogger OF / 1B / Broadway, VA / 2027

‘27 Jackson Plogger (@BwayBaseballVA)

Stays on this 2K breaking ball for a line drive single into center.

Shows barrel control with adjustability.@ksallday19 @PrepBaseballVA #BeSeen https://t.co/QABp4FFwAM pic.twitter.com/6h7FciLjcj
— Jordan Jones (@JJonesPBVADC) April 16, 2025

First Base

Jaron Wyatt 1B / LHP / CENTRAL HIGH, VA / 2027

Catchers

Mason Archer SS / C / HAYFIELD SECONDARY, VA / 2027

Gavin Gilbert C / RHP / William Monroe, VA / 2027

‘27 Gavin Gilbert (@WMHSBaseball643)

First hit of the night for William Monroe. Works a 2K count and singles through the right side. @PrepBaseballVA #BeSeen pic.twitter.com/6l7Fbe3zeu
— Prep Baseball VA/DC Scouting (@PrepBaseVAS) April 8, 2025

Abe Jaspen C / RHP / CHARLOTTESVILLE HIGH, VA / 2027

Braxton Price C / 2B / John S. Battle High, VA / 2028

‘28 Braxton Price sends a 2K single to RCF to give @BattleBaseball1 a 12-5 lead in B3. #MountainDistrictTourney pic.twitter.com/Cth89bAufb
— Prep Baseball Virginia/DC (@PrepBaseballVA) May 20, 2025

Two-Way

Cohen Berkley C / 3B / Central High School (Lunenburg), VA / 2027

Peyton Conley RHP / 2B / Smith Mountain Lake Christian Academy, VA / 2029

‘29 Peyton Conley (SMLCA)

Came in relief, works a repeatable and slower paced windup with late intent from a L 3/4 slot. Has worked mainly with the FB at 85-87 T89, mixed in some CH’s at 76-78, and utilized the SL with late sweep as the S/M pitch at 73-75. @PrepBaseballVA… pic.twitter.com/HpEpYt9dy4
— Prep Baseball VA/DC Scouting (@PrepBaseVAS) April 17, 2025

Jack Guerin SS / RHP / DC, Washington - St Albans, DC / 2028

‘28 Jack Guerin (@STA1Baseball)

Stretch only delivery with compact arm action from 3/4 slot. Working the outer half with the FB sitting 82-84. Bigger shaped breaking ball at 68-71. #CommonwealthClassic pic.twitter.com/ed2jI34uE8
— Prep Baseball Virginia/DC (@PrepBaseballVA) April 12, 2025

Chandler Howlett SS / 2B / WALSINGHAM ACADEMY, VA / 2027

‘27 Chandler Howlett (@WATrojan)

Works the count and sends a line drive into LF for a leadoff single.@VISAABaseball #VISAA2025 pic.twitter.com/GDgTrRhaCa
— Prep Baseball Virginia/DC (@PrepBaseballVA) May 17, 2025

Hayden Reed LHP / OF / ABINGDON HIGH, VA / 2027

Justin Tucker 1B / RHP / Northside, VA / 2027

‘27 Justin Tucker (@NorthsideBaseb2)

Sees this pitch up with 2K’s and sends it out of LF for a solo 💣 in the bottom of the third.@PrepBaseballVA #BeSeen https://t.co/2MadoCKAZk pic.twitter.com/SJLSnMejLv
— Prep Baseball VA/DC Scouting (@PrepBaseVAS) April 17, 2025

Utility/DH

Isaac Elder SS / 3B / JEFFERSON FOREST HIGH, VA / 2028

‘28 Issac Elder (@JFcavsbaseball)

Turns the barrel here for a line drive single to LF. #VHSLRegion4D pic.twitter.com/aD6IXfxHgR
— Prep Baseball Virginia/DC (@PrepBaseballVA) June 4, 2025