Prep Baseball Report

Best of Fall: Top Catchers


Brandon Hall
NC / Mid-ATL Director of Scouting

Best of the Fall: 2025 Edition

The 2025 fall season featured some of the highest-quality events in the region, giving players the chance to measure themselves against the top talent in their state, class, and even nationally. From Scout Days to ID events and Top Prospect Games, athletes tested their skills in pro-style workouts, live competition, and advanced analytics sessions. Players updating their profiles through these events now connect with over 1,000 college programs and every MLB organization that subscribes to Prep Baseball’s trusted information, ensuring their performance is seen by the right eyes.

Best of the Fall 2026: Catcher Defensive Leaders — Pop Times & Positional Velocity

As part of our Best of the Fall 2026 series, today we focus on the defensive side of the game behind the plate, highlighting catchers who stood out for pop times and positional arm velocity during fall events across North Carolina.

Catcher defensive evaluations were conducted through simulated stolen base attempts, with catchers working from the crouch and making throws to second base. This game-like setup allows Prep Baseball staff to evaluate how quickly and efficiently catchers move through their transfer and release, while also capturing arm velocity, pop times, and high-quality video.

These metrics—paired with video—provide college coaches and professional scouts on the Prep Baseball platform with a detailed look at a catcher’s defensive ability. The leaderboards below feature both overall leaders from the fall and class-by-class standouts, spotlighting catchers whose defensive tools separated themselves in live-action evaluations.


DEFENSIVE LEADERS - CATCHERS

CATCHER ARM VELOCITY - FROM THE CROUCH

Rank Name State School Class Pos C Velo
1 Brady Maxwell NC Pro 5 2027 C 81
2 Lawson Tyndall NC Eastern Carolina Academy 2029 C 80
3 Hayden Willoughby NC DH Conley 2027 C 79
^ Harrison Mears NC South Brunswick 2027 C 79
^ Jack Catron NC Homeschool (NC) 2028 C 79
4 Tyson Cameron NC Pro5 Academy 2028 C 78
5 Jack May NC Western Alamance 2028 C 77

2026 GRADS

Rank Name State School Class Pos C Velo
1 Jayce Huneycutt NC North Stanly 2026 C 76
2 Noah Funderburk NC Porter Ridge 2026 C 65
3 Westin Tompkins NC Walkertown 2026 C 61

2027 GRADS

Rank Name State School Class Pos C Velo
1 Brady Maxwell NC Pro 5 2027 C 81
2 Hayden Willoughby NC DH Conley 2027 C 79
^ Harrison Mears NC South Brunswick 2027 C 79
3 Brody Stephens NC First Flight 2027 C 76
^ Maddox Deans NC Southern Nash 2027 C 76
^ Cooper Marks NC Walter M Williams 2027 SS 76
4 Davis Brinson NC Ayden-Grifton High 2027 C 75
^ Cooper Diehl SC Fort Mill High 2027 C 75
5 Luke Waters NC Southern Lee High School 2027 C 71

2028 GRADS

Rank Name State School Class Pos C Velo
1 Jack Catron NC Homeschool (NC) 2028 C 79
2 Tyson Cameron NC Pro5 Academy 2028 C 78
3 Jack May NC Western Alamance 2028 C 77
4 Lincoln Lawson NC Randleman 2028 C 76
5 Kellan Coleman NC Topsail 2028 C 74

2029 GRADS

Rank Name State School Class Pos C Velo
1 Lawson Tyndall NC Eastern Carolina Academy 2029 C 80
2 Clark Johnson NC Eastern Carolina Academy 2029 C 75
^ Grayson Durrant NC Pro5 Academy 2029 C 75
3 Chase Kafes NC Heritage 2029 C 74
4 Avery Cooney NC Carrboro 2029 C 73
5 Teagan Nickerson NC Eastern Carolina Academy 2029 C 72

CATCHER POP TIMES

Rank Name State School Class Pos Pop Time
1 Harrison Mears NC South Brunswick 2027 C 1.91-2.00
2 Westin Tompkins NC Walkertown 2026 C 1.91-2.01
3 Brady Maxwell NC Pro 5 2027 C 1.93-2.00
4 Jack May NC Western Alamance 2028 C 1.93-2.12
5 Camden Lusk GA Fayetteville Tech CC 2023 C 1.94-2.08
6 James Stalls NC Faith Christian School 2028 C 1.97-2.08
7 Lawson Tyndall NC Eastern Carolina Academy 2029 C 1.98-2.08
8 Hayden Willoughby NC DH Conley 2027 C 1.98-2.15
9 Davis Brinson NC Ayden-Grifton High 2027 C 2.00-2.16
10 Brody Stephens NC First Flight 2027 C 2.01-2.14

2026 GRADS

Rank Name State School Class Pos Pop Time
1 Westin Tompkins NC Walkertown 2026 C 1.91-2.01
2 Jayce Huneycutt NC North Stanly 2026 C 2.20-2.25
3 Noah Funderburk NC Porter Ridge 2026 C 2.26-2.50

2027 GRADS

Rank Name State School Class Pos Pop Time
1 Harrison Mears NC South Brunswick 2027 C 1.91-2.00
2 Brady Maxwell NC Pro 5 2027 C 1.93-2.00
3 Hayden Willoughby NC DH Conley 2027 C 1.98-2.15
4 Davis Brinson NC Ayden-Grifton High 2027 C 2.00-2.16
5 Brody Stephens NC First Flight 2027 C 2.01-2.14

2028 GRADS

Rank Name State School Class Pos Pop Time
1 Jack May NC Western Alamance 2028 C 1.93-2.12
2 James Stalls NC Faith Christian School 2028 C 1.97-2.08
3 Noah Price NC Cleveland 2028 C 2.04-2.12
4 Tyson Cameron NC Pro5 Academy 2028 C 2.05-2.12
5 Jack Catron NC Homeschool (NC) 2028 C 2.05-2.15

2029 GRADS

Rank Name State School Class Pos Pop Time
1 Lawson Tyndall NC Eastern Carolina Academy 2029 C 1.98-2.08
2 Clark Johnson NC Eastern Carolina Academy 2029 C 2.06-2.16
3 Tristan Stewart NC Hoggard 2029 C 2.07-2.20
4 Teagan Nickerson NC Eastern Carolina Academy 2029 C 2.08-2.26
5 Chase Kafes NC Heritage 2029 C 2.10-2.19


Best of Fall 2025