2025 Signing Day: Division I Breakdown
December 3, 2025
Indiana's 2026 class currently has 56 Division I recruits who are set to sign, or have signed their letter of intent since Novemeber 13th. Read along to learn where these recruits are headed to play college baseball at the Divison I level, with a break down of in-state & out-of-state recruits.
*Rankings indicative of internal board, set to update on Tuesday, December 9th*
Indiana Divison I Programs
Indiana
- In-State Recruits : 5
- # Top 50 Ranked Players (Indiana) : 5
- # Nationally Ranked Players : 5
- Top Ranked In-State Recruit : 3B Aiden Reynolds
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. (Rank) |
| Aiden Reynolds | 8 | Noblesville | 3B (1) |
| Jake Winger | 10 | McCutcheon | 3B (2) |
| Jaxon Lueken | 12 | Forest Park | RHP (5) |
| Collin Marcum | 13 | Bloomington South | RHP (6) |
| Logan Johnston | 14 | Crown Point | RHP (7) |
Notre Dame
- In-State Recruits : 2
- # Top 50 Ranked Players (Indiana) : 2
- # Nationally Ranked Players : 1
- Top Ranked In-State Recruit : OF Desmond Francis
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. |
| Desmond Francis | 16 | Park Tudor | OF (2) |
| Rhys Wolf | 25 | Martinsville | RHP (11) |
Purdue
- In-State Recruits : 2
- # Top 50 Ranked Players (Indiana) : 2
- # Nationally Ranked Players : 0
- Top Ranked In-State Recruit : RHP Cayden Stockbridge
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. (Rank) |
| Cayden Stockbridge | 21 | Penn | RHP (10) |
| Troy Barrett | 23 | Chesterton | LHP (4) |
Ball State
- In-State Recruits : 2
- # Top 50 Ranked Players (Indiana) : 2
- # Nationally Ranked Players : 0
- Top Ranked In-State Recruit : RHP/SS Trey Deckman
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. |
| Trey Deckman | 24 | Columbia City | SS (5) |
| Kellen Thomson | 30 | Center Grove | RHP (13) |
Indiana State
- In-State Recruits : 4
- # Top 50 Ranked Players (Indiana) : 2
- # Nationally Ranked Players : 0
- Top Ranked In-State Recruit : 3B Gavin Jackson
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. |
| Gavin Jackson | 40 | Providence | 3B (3) |
| Alton Otsby | 45 | Washington | RHP (18) |
| Briar Goda | 52 | Terre Haute North | OF (9) |
| Nate Millington | 54 | Terre Haute North | SS (11) |
Valparaiso
- In-State Recruits : 2
- # of Top 50 Ranked Players (Indiana) : 1
- # of Nationally Ranked Players : 0
- Top Ranked In-State Recruit : 3B Aidan Creasbaum
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. |
| Aidan Creasbaum | 41 | Hanover Central | 3B (4) |
| Collin Ash | 48 | Roncalli | OF (8) |
Evansville
- In-State Recruits : 3
- # Top 50 Ranked Players (Indiana) : 2
- # Nationally Ranked Players : 0
- Top Ranked In-State Recruit : RHP Matthew Cook
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. |
| Matthew Cook | 20 | Hanover Central | RHP (9) |
| Owen Lukac | 29 | Fishers | LHP (5) |
| Brooks Carroll | 74 | Evansville | SS (17) |
Southern Indiana
- In-State Recruits : 1
- # Top 50 Ranked Players (Indiana) : 0
- # Nationally Ranked Players : 0
- Top Ranked In-State Recruit : RHP Mason Hamlett
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. |
| Mason Hamlett | 119 | South Dearborn | RHP (45) |
Recruits headed to Out-of-State Division I Programs & Conference Breakdown
SEC
- # of Indiana Recruits : 8
- # of Top 50 Ranked Players (Indiana) : 8
- # of Nationally Ranked Players : 8
- Top Ranked Indiana Recruit : C Sean Dunlap (Tennessee)
ACC
- # of Indiana Recruits : 2
- # of Top 50 Ranked Players (Indiana) : 2
- # of Nationally Ranked Players :1
- Top Ranked Indiana Recruit : OF Desmond Francis (Notre Dame)
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. (Rank) | Commitment |
| Desmond Francis | 16 | Park Tudor | OF (2) | Notre Dame |
| Rhys Wolf | 25 | Martinsville | RHP (11) | Notre Dame |
Big 12
- # of Indiana Recruits : 1
- # of Top 50 Ranked Players (Indiana) :1
- # of Nationally Ranked Players : 1
- Top Ranked Indiana Recruit : SS Dylan Bowen (Oklahoma State)
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. (Rank) | Commitment |
| Dylan Bowen | 3 | Hanover Central | SS (1) | Oklahoma State |
Big 10
- # of Indiana Recruits : 9
- # of Top 50 Ranked Players (Indiana) : 9
- # of Nationally Ranked Players : 6
- Top Ranked Indiana Recruit : 3B Aiden Reynolds (Indiana)
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. (Rank) | Commitment |
| Aiden Reynolds | 8 | Noblesville | 3B (1) | Indiana |
| Jake Winger | 10 | McCutcheon | 3B (2) | Indiana |
| Caden Matusak | 11 | Crown Point | SS (2) | Michigan |
| Jaxon Lueken | 12 | Forest Park | RHP (5) | Indiana |
| Collin Marcum | 13 | Bloomington South | RHP (6) | Indiana |
| Logan Johnston | 14 | Crown Point | RHP (7) | Indiana |
| Cayden Stockbridge | 21 | Penn | RHP (10) | Purdue |
| Kaden Maxwell | 22 | Andrean | LHP (3) | Illinois |
| Troy Barrett | 23 | Chesterton | LHP (4) | Purdue |
Big East
- # of Indiana Recruits : 1
- # of Top 50 Ranked Players (Indiana) :1
- # of Nationally Ranked Players : 1
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. (Rank) | Commitment |
| Ryan Murphy | 19 | Brownsburg | LHP (2) | Creighton |
Mid American Conference
- # of Indiana Recruits : 6
- # of Top 50 Ranked Players (Indiana) : 4
- # of Nationally Ranked Players : 0
- Top Ranked Indiana Recruits : RHP/SS Trey Deckman (Ball State)
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. | Commitment |
| Trey Deckman | 24 | Columbia City | SS (5) | Ball State |
| Kellen Thomson | 30 | Center Grove | RHP (13) | Ball State |
| Reed Robinson | 32 | New Prairie | C (2) | Northern Illinois |
| EJ Milliner | 39 | Floyd Central | OF (6) | Central Michigan |
| Tanner Post | 53 | Illiana Christian | LHP (6) | Toledo |
| Jonathan Riley | 72 | McCutcheon | OF (15) | Toledo |
Atlantic Sun
- # of Indiana Recruits : 5
- # of Top 50 Ranked Players (Indiana) : 2
- # of Nationally Ranked Players : 0
- Top Ranked Indiana Recruit : RHP Jeremy Lowrey (Stetson)
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. | Commitment |
| Jeremy Lowrey | 31 | Harrison | RHP (14) | Stetson |
| Peter Ward | 38 | Zionsville | RHP (17) | Bellarmine |
| Liam Smith | 68 | Bloomington North | 3B (5) | Bellarmine |
| Rykin Matthias | 70 | North Central | OF (13) | Bellarmine |
| Vince Painter | 91 | Brownsburg | RHP (34) | Bellarmine |
Atlantic 10
- # of Indiana Recruits : 4
- # of Top 50 Ranked Players : 2
- # of Nationally Ranked Players : 1
- Top Ranked Indiana Recruit : SS Lannon Nicoloff (George Mason)
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. | Commitment |
| Lannon Nicoloff | 18 | Harrison | SS (4) | George Mason |
| Ian Taylor | 27 | Guerin Catholic | OF (3) | George Mason |
| Hudson Stewart | 69 | Center Grove | OF (12) | Dayton |
| Jackson Mitchell | 73 | George Mason | RHP (27) | George Mason |
Missouri Valley
- # of Indiana Recruits : 9
- # of Top 50 Ranked Players : 5
- # of Nationally Ranked Players : 0
- Top Ranked Indiana Recruit : RHP Matthew Cook (Evansville)
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. | Commitment |
| Matthew Cook | 20 | Hanover Central | RHP (9) | Evansville |
| Owen Lukac | 29 | Fishers | LHP (5) | Evansville |
| Gavin Jackson | 40 | Providence | 3B (3) | Indiana State |
| Aidan Creasbaum | 41 | Hanover Central | 3B (4) | Valparaiso |
| Alton Ostby | 45 | Washington | RHP (18) | Indiana State |
| Collin Ash | 48 | Roncalli | OF (8) | Valparaiso |
| Briar Goda | 52 | Terre Haute North | OF (9) | Indiana State |
| Nate Millington | 54 | Terre Haute North | SS (12) | Indiana State |
| Brooks Carroll | 74 | Evansville North | SS (17) | Evansville |
American Athletic Conference
- # of Indiana Recruits : 3
- # of Top 50 Ranked Players : 3
- # of Nationally Ranked Players : 0
- Top Ranked Indiana Recruit : RHP Gavin Lykins (Plainfield)
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. | Commitment |
| Gavin Lykins | 26 | Plainfield | RHP (12) | South Florida |
| Blake Cope | 28 | Zionsville | OF (4) | Wichita State |
| Beckett Suh | 34 | University | SS (7) | Tulane |
Conference USA
- # of Indiana Recruits : 2
- # of Top 50 Ranked Players : 2
- # of Nationally Ranked Players : 1
- Top Ranked Indiana Recruit : SS Peyton Gray (Western Kentucky)
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. | Commitment |
| Peyton Gray | 17 | Heritage Hills | SS (3) | Western Kentucky |
| Jake Mazzier | 37 | Gibson Southern | RHP (16) | Western Kentucky |
Patriot League
- # of Indiana Recruits : 1
- # of Top 50 Ranked Players:1
- # of Nationally Ranked Players : 0
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. | Commitment |
| Eli Sinsabaugh | 33 | Cathedral | SS (6) | Army |
Ivy League
- # of Indiana Recruits : 1
- # of Top 50 Ranked Players :1
- # of Nationally Ranked Players : 0
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. | Commitment |
| Connor Couch | 35 | Bloomington South | RHP (15) | Columbia |
Sun Belt
- # of Indiana Recruits : 1
- # of Top 50 Ranked Players :1
- # of Nationally Ranked Players : 0
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. | Commitment |
| Jace Watson | 36 | Castle | OF (5) | Old Dominion |
Horizon League
- # of Indiana Recruits : 1
- # of Top 50 Ranked Players : 0
- # of Nationally Ranked Players : 0
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. | Commitment |
| Greyson Betts | 64 | Franklin Community | RHP (24) | Northern Kentucky |
Ohio Valley Conference
- # of Indiana Recruits : 2
- # of Top 50 Ranked Players :0
- # of Nationally Ranked Players : 0
- Top Ranked Indiana Recruit : C Ryan Rodman (Eastern Illinois)
| Name | Rank | School | Pos. | Commitment |
| Ryan Rodman | 85 | Western | C (7) | Eastern Illinois |
| Mason Hamlett | 119 | South Dearborn | RHP (45) | Southern Indiana |